BOULDER — It’s one thing to keep moving the goalposts for Deion Sanders. But who takes them down for … K-State?
4-4 Kansas State?
4-4 and 1-4 in the Big 12 Kansas State?
4-4 and playing-its-third-string-and-fourth-string QBs Kansas State?
4-4 and shoulda-gone-for-two Kansas State?
CU Buffs students do, apparently.
Says a lot.
Not all of it kind.
“Our fan base is great,” Buffs tight end Charlie Williams said after his 11-yard touchdown grab in overtime sealed a wacky, field-storming 27-24 win over the Wildcats. “We love it. Kinda crazy because the field goal posts started coming down, and I was like, ‘All right, they’re storming the field.'”
For … that?
Yeah, we know, we know. Halloween weekend. Noon kick. Hangover special. CU students finally saw the Buffs’ (3-5, 1-4 Big 12) five-game losing streak snapped. They finally saw a nine-game Big 12 losing skid snapped. Saturday was the first time the Buffs had scored more than 24 points against a Power 4 opponent since a 52-0 demolition of Oklahoma State in November 2024.
Let ’em have their fun, right? Fine. But know this: Storming the field for an overtime win over a team you should’ve run out of the building — especially when you pile up a season-best 222 rushing yards — sure is a curious look for a program with championship aspirations. It’s awfully … well … 2022.
“Should have never went to overtime, I feel,” Sanders, now 19-26 over four seasons at CU, 10-22 in league contests, reflected later. “(We) allowed some crazy things to happen.”
The craziest stuff happened midway through the second quarter and right at the end of regulation. CU had Kansas State on the ropes at least twice. The Buffs should’ve put the QB-challenged Wildcats away just before halftime, only to fumble away a 13-0 lead out of the back of the K-State end zone.
The second K-State escape was more painful. CU was trying to salt away the clock while nursing a 21-14 lead with 50 seconds left. The Wildcats, behind former Erie quarterback Blake Barnett, got the ball back at their own 38.
And for the next 46 seconds, Colorado Avenue became Blake Street.
Barnett, tougher than old boots, completed a 23-yard pass to the Buffs’ 39. Then a 5-yard toss. On second-and-5 at the CU 34, K-State wideout Jaron Tibbs beat the Buff defense for a 31-yard gain to the Buffs’ 3. On third-and-goal from the Buffs’ 8-yard line, Barnett, on what looked like one good leg, squeezed a ball into tight end Garrett Oakley for a score with two seconds left to bring K-State to within 21-20.
In a decision he would probably regret later, Collin Klein, the first-year Wildcats coach and former Loveland High standout, chose to kick the extra point after initially lining up for a 2-point conversion to win in regulation.
Williams gave Sanders a Halloween treat to remember. And Klein is going to be kicking himself all the way back to Manhattan.
In hindsight, maybe it was only apropos for one of the weirdest weeks of the Coach Prime Era at CU — with Sanders denying he would pay critics $50,000 not to talk about him and national media buzzards circling a Buffs squad back in the Big 12 basement — to end with one of the strangest games at Folsom in recent memory. For one week, at least, the “buyout” chatter gets a sweet reprieve.
“It takes a lot of pressure off, honestly,” Buffs safety Randon Fontenette said. “There was a lot of chatter (this week) that I don’t even want to speak on… It felt like a dark cloud over this place… it’s a huge relief.”
Klein and his ‘Cats (4-4, 1-4) got the version of CU that the Buffs flashed in the second half here in a near-miss against Texas Tech and in the first half last weekend in Stillwater. Tailback Richard Young accounted for 120 yards and two TDs on 24 carries. Running mate JaQuail Smith added 63 on the ground.
From discipline to play-calling, this was Peak Buffs. Desperate Buffs. Urgent Buffs. CU was flagged for just 53 yards in penalties and turned it over only once. Sanders and offensive coordinator Brennan Marion leaned on the run game and punter Damon Greaves to leverage better field position rather than trusting QB Isaac Wilson in a one-score game.
Good call. The Buffs ran where they wanted, when they wanted, for the most part. Young’s 22-yard TD sprint three minutes into the final stanza capped a 10-play, 96-yard scoring drive that put the hosts up 20-14 before the extra point.
And, in hindsight, it shouldn’t have been that close. Special teams miscues continue to nag. Running with a return right after signaling for a fair catch. An illegal formation call on a fourth-quarter CU punt gave the Wildcats 22 more yards of field position after the second return.
A noon kick on a Halloween Saturday was always going to be a tough sell for college kids on a holiday weekend. And the first quarter was notable for the number of students who came disguised as empty seats. The crowd did trickle in before halftime, though, and those who remained for the duration came away with plenty to talk about.
K-State rolled into town without its top two QB options in Avery Johnson and Jacob Knuth. With Dillon Duff and Barnett warming up, Klein chose the former — a sophomore out of St. Louis making his collegiate debut. It showed. The visitors had all of two passing yards by the start of the second quarter.
But just as CU, which was already up 7-0, looked ready to put this bad boy away early, the football gods had other ideas.
The Buffs marched upfield quickly behind a 19-yard Wilson toss to DeAndre Moore Jr. to the K-State 40 and two Young runs that brought up a second-and-7 at the Wildcats’ 30. DeKalon Taylor took a pitch from his QB and exploded with the rock up the left boundary and raced into the end zone — which is where K-State, literally, got cheeky.
As Taylor reached the 1-yard line, Wildcat cornerback Kaleb Patterson went for the CU back’s legs and, as a result, hit the runner’s hands with his hindquarters. The ball squirted out like a wet bar of soap before rolling all the way out of the back of the end zone for a K-State touchback.
The Buffs were inches from a 13-0 lead before the turnover, but the fine margins bit Sanders’ team in the backside again.
“I don’t know what the definition of ‘desperation’ is. I don’t think these young men are desperate,” Sanders said later. “The main thing I told them to do is go out there and have fun. It’s impossible to have fun when you get your butt kicked.”
The desperate know better than to complain about a little light that breaks through all those dark clouds. Even when it’s 4-4 … K-State.
Even a dying dog has a good day, now and again, before the inevitable closes in and the goalposts come down for a long winter’s nap. For the first time since Georgia Tech, CU snatched a victory from someone in its weight class. With four winnable games left on the fight card, including road trips to Arizona State and Cincinnati, we’ll know soon enough if Sanders’ fourth team is actually ready for Prime Time.