That’s it. That’s all she wrote. Whoever she might be, the story of the 2023 Kentucky football season featured a thrilling introduction, lost some readers midway through, and then brought it all together with a poetic albeit sad ending. I doubt many fans of the series will read it again but most would probably recommend it to a friend and look forward to the author’s next book, which comes out in about eight months.
Let’s forget about the crazy, drunken Taxslayer Gator Bowl for just a moment, and instead take a sobering review of the entire year.
Throughout this season, we have leaned on the analytical wisdom of Power Football Focus (PFF) to give all of us football Bennies (hmm…that doesn’t have the same ring to it as the basketball version) a simplistic numerical measurement of how each player performed in a given game. The eye test can usually tell a strong story, but if you weren’t watching the left guard’s pass blocking, PFF provided a nice little grade to let you know what you missed.
For quick reference, here are the PFF grades for every Kentucky game this season:
While combing through how each player graded out after each game is a great way to confirm your gut feelings following a big win or disappointing loss, it is now time to zoom out and assess the team as a whole and see how it stacked up against the rest of the SEC and recent Kentucky teams.
(Note: these season grades do not include bowl games)
Overall Grade
The overall grade is the one that matters right? When you’re taking the ACT, sure you care what you got in the reading and science categories, but the score that matters is the cumulative one.
Kentucky finished the 2023 year with an overall PFF grade of 84.8. That ranks them 42nd out of 133 teams in FBS, 28th in the Power Five conferences, and 8th in the SEC.
Kentucky’s highest overall individual grade came against Akron, where they posted an 89.4. The worst came against Georgia, where they graded out at just 49.5. The Bulldogs will make anyone look bad, but Kentucky was all out of sorts that day.
Finishing 8th in the SEC in overall PFF grade feels about right considering the ‘Cats also finished with the 8th-best record. Before the season, Big Blue Nation envisioned the Wildcats to have the success Missouri enjoyed, but that was not the case. That being said, the Tigers’ 10-2 record equated to an overall PFF grade of 90.5, good for 16th in Power Five conferences, and 5th in the SEC.
As mediocre of a season as fans may have perceived 2023 to be, Kentucky finished with the 4th best overall PFF grade of the Stoops era. These numbers only go back to 2014, but it is safe to say Stoops’ 2-10 season in 2013 did not grade well.
Seeing these numbers in chart format makes you go back and realize how special those 2021 and 2018 seasons were.
Historical Overall PFF Grades for Kentucky Football since 2014
Offense
Liam Coen came back to Lexington to implement his pro-style offense and reignite a stagnant 2022 scoring output. However, as the old saying goes, the best-laid plans of ‘Cats and offensive coordinators often go astray.
Kentucky finished dead last in the entire country in plays run per game. Several factors went into this but ultimately, Kentucky ran the clock down to nearly zero on every play and then did not move the ball with any sort of efficiency all year.
PFF graded the team’s overall offensive performance with a 76, which ranked them 56th in FBS, 29th in the Power Five, and 8th in the SEC. For comparison sake, Coen’s last season as OC featured an offensive grade of 93.2, and the Scangarello experiment last season graded out at 74.6.
What really helped Kentucky was their run game. Led by Ray Davis, who had the 11th-best individual run grade in the country, Kentucky did most of their damage on the ground. Their overall 93.2 run grade was third-best in the SEC behind only Ole Miss and LSU.
What makes Kentucky’s run grade more impressive is its below-average run-block grade. At 55.9, the Big Blue Wall did not do Ray Davis any favors and ranked 12th in the SEC. Still, Davis persevered.
You don’t need analytics to know the passing game is what held Kentucky’s offense back. It isn’t that Devin Leary was bad (he wasn’t), but a passing grade of 70.3 (10th in SEC) showcases the inconsistency of the Wildcats’ air attack.
Defense
Although it did not feel like it at times (especially on third and long or when trying to hold the lead in a bowl game), Kentucky’s defense held up fairly well according to PFF. Brad White’s unit finished with an overall defensive grade of 84.7, good for 41st in FBS, 23rd in the Power Five, and 5th in the SEC.
Shaky tackling and a lack of any sort of meaningful pass rush prevented Kentucky from excelling but the ‘Cats featured a stout run defense (PFF grade of 82.8 [5th in SEC]) and above-average pass coverage (PFF grade of 84.2 [6th in SEC].
Up front, it all started and stopped with Deone Walker. The behemoth who wears #0 finished 2nd in the SEC and 18th in the country amongst interior defense linemen who played at least 300 snaps in defensive rating with an 82. To drill down further, Walker also graded out as the second-best rush-defender among interior linemen and 15th-best in the country with a rating of 82.5.
As for pass coverage, Maxwell Hairston reigned supreme. On top of his five interceptions (some of which inexplicably came while wearing a cast on his wrist), Hairston’s 83.5 overall defensive rating placed him as the 9th-best cornerback in the SEC. It would have likely been even higher if he had been healthy all season.
Kentucky’s bend-but-don’t-break defensive philosophy broke a lot of this season, usually when it mattered most. However, as a whole, it is hard to call them a failure. If they could have wrapped up a few more tackles here and there (10th in the SEC in tacking grade) and found a way to get more pressure on the quarterback, the ‘Cats may have been able to squeak out another win or two.
Alas, the numbers are what they are. On to next year.
SEC PFF Grades for the 2023 Season