FITCHBURG, Wis. (WMTV) - Some Fitchburg residents are voicing frustration after the city approved a new $40 annual vehicle registration fee—commonly referred to as a “wheel tax”—on Tuesday.
The Fitchburg Common Council approved the proposal requiring residents to pay the annual vehicle registration fee during a meeting Tuesday night. While the decision has sparked concern, city officials argue the fee is a necessary measure to help maintain services amid rising costs and a steadily growing population.
District 3 Alder Donald Dantzler, who voted in favor of the tax, acknowledged that it was a difficult decision. He understands the added financial burden on residents but warns that without this funding, essential services such as transportation, police, and fire departments could suffer.
Responding to criticism that the tax was rushed through, Dantzler emphasized that the proposal had been discussed in multiple public meetings, posted on the city website, and that council members had received community input before the final vote.
“I do want folks to know that this Council is not in the business of recklessly spending,” Dantzler said. “We’re not trying to further disadvantage those individuals who are disadvantaged, but trying to meet the needs of a growing and thriving municipality and do the best with the resources that we’re able to obtain.”
However, many residents feel the move is out of touch with the public’s financial reality. Katie Sellner, a retired Metro Transit planner and longtime Fitchburg resident, was among those who spoke out against the tax during the council meeting. She argued that the fee is a regressive form of taxation, placing a disproportionate burden on those with fixed or lower incomes.
Sellner and others have also voiced frustration over what they see as the city’s disregard for public input. They point to the fact that a tax-increase referendum was rejected by voters just five months ago, yet city officials proceeded with the wheel tax despite strong opposition expressed during public comment and on social media.
Dantzler is also urging Wisconsin residents to push state lawmakers to increase municipal support using the state’s budget surplus. He noted that Fitchburg is not alone—many municipalities across Wisconsin are grappling with financial pressures and need additional state aid to avoid passing more costs onto local taxpayers.
“I believe that Dane County, I mean specifically, Fitchburg has gotten its fair share of the funds allocated from the state legislature. However, they are still sitting on a pretty large surplus that could be disseminated to various municipalities to help with some of these issues.”
The proposal passed after Mayor Julia Arata-Fratta cast the tie-breaking vote in a 4-4 split.
The new fee is expected to generate around $1 million in revenue, most of which will be used for transportation-related expenses. This, in turn, will allow the city to reallocate other funds toward law enforcement and general operational needs.
The $40 annual fee will be added to vehicles with registration expiring in August or any vehicle registered on or after Aug. 1. The Wisconsin Department of Transportation will collect the fee at the time of registration or renewal.
Fitchburg officials note that 48 cities and 13 counties in Wisconsin have already enacted—or are planning to enact—a vehicle registration fee.
Click here to download the WMTV15 News app or our WMTV15 First Alert weather app.
Copyright 2025 WMTV. All rights reserved.