Recently, a group of guys were gathered together in a quest to find and reward them for lives linked to one of the movies’ most famous killers
As names for horror movie villains go, Michael Myers is certainly not the scariest one someone can imagine — so it should come as no surprise that there are plenty of Mr. Myerses out there in the world, sans slasher accessories.
Recently, a group of those guys were gathered together as part of a quest to find and reward them for lives forever linked to one of the movies’ most famous killers. (No, the Austin Powers star didn’t join in.)
Voodoo Ranger set out to locate the real-life Michael Myers ahead of Halloween as part of its Slasher Manhunt, which celebrates Slasher IPA, the company’s collaboration with Halloween: The Game.
The silent killer has been delighting and terrifying moviegoers in equal measure since his debut in the 1978 Halloween, directed by John Carpenter and starring Jamie Lee Curtis.
Since then, the franchise has grown to 13 movies, including the most recent release, 2022’s Halloween Ends.
The beer company received 400 entries in total, about 80 of which were true submissions from people named Michael Myers or Meyers.
Eleven people won. Michael Meyers of Safety Harbor, Fla., was one of them after entering the contest at a friend’s urging.
The PEOPLE stories you love, with first access and special features reserved for subscribers.
“He’s like, ‘Hey, you need to enter this. This is you. You live it,’ ” the 50-year-old tells PEOPLE.
Meyers was born in 1975, just three years before Halloween debuted in theaters. He recalls seeing the first two movies in the series when he was about 10 at a drive-in in New York, where he grew up. He’s since seen all of the films in the franchise and says the later Rob Zombie entries are among his favorites.
“I would probably get some criticism for saying [that],” he quips while adding, “I liked a little bit more of the story. Like, ‘Who am I?’ Give me some more insight on this guy.”
The real-life Meyers “fed into” his connection to the Halloween lore as a kid, he says — “It was always, ‘Don’t mess with Michael Myers,’ stuff like that,” he recalls — but he truly leaned into the character as an adult when he got a full back tattoo featuring the masked killer.
The work took almost three years to complete, through a series of four-hour sessions, and cost about $6,000 in total.
“I said, ‘Listen, I don’t want just throw Michael Myers on my back. I want it to be a story,’ ” says Meyers, whose art pays homage to his childhood in New York (where he would drive by the “Amityville Horror” house), time spent living in Las Vegas and his eventual move to Florida.
“My friends always make me show it off whenever we’re out,” Meyers says of the ink, noting that his neighbors also get a kick out of the tattoo whenever they see him outside without a shirt. (“It’s Florida. There’s a lot of times we’re not gonna wear a shirt,” he says with a laugh.)
Meyers says that his moniker can be a bit of a headache at times, recalling one Halloween when he tried to rent a tile grinder at a hardware store and was almost denied because of his name. The employee had been given fake IDs before by customers who never returned their tools to the store and was “super cautious” with Meyers, he says.
“He’s just like, ‘This is fake. It’s Halloween and this guy just made this thing,’ and he didn’t believe me,” Meyers says. “And I’m showing him my credit cards. I’m like, ‘Bro, we can’t make up all of these.’ ”
While he’s fully embraced his name now, he didn’t always love it.
“There was a very small time where I hated the name because people were referencing me to Michael Myers, the comedian from Austin Powers,” he says. “I was like, ‘No, I’m the killer Michael Myers. Don’t confuse me.’ ”
Another Michael Myers — of Urbana, Ill. — didn’t always love his name either, but for reasons a bit different from his Florida counterpart, he says.
“When I was younger, it was all I ever heard: ‘Oh, Michael Myers, Michael Myers.’ As a kid, you get annoyed by it. You just wanna have a normal name,” says Myers, 41, who also won a prize in the Voodoo Ranger contest after a friend told him to apply after hearing about it on the radio. (Winners got a year’s worth of beer and a copy of the Halloween game.)
“I was like, ‘Hey, what do I got to lose? I might as well put my name in the hat,’ ” Myers tells PEOPLE.
Despite the connection, he hasn’t seen any of the Halloween movies in their entirety. He says he is more of an Insidious fan, but he’s also trying to slowly introduce his own son to horror movies — at least those that are appropriate for a 4-year-old.
Myers, who is also dad to a 5-year-old son, tells PEOPLE he and his youngest have watched Hocus Pocus and the Goosebumps series, and he’s hoping to eventually introduce him to Jaws if it’s not too scary.
For now, they’re holding off on watching anything from the Halloween franchise.
However, the movie has found its way into Myers’ everyday life through his work as an arborist, where some clients will poke fun when they learn his name.
“They’ll kind of joke around about, ‘Are you bringing a chainsaw?’ ” he says. “You know, ‘Yeah, I’m bringing a chainsaw. I’ll be there.’ Most of the time, they keep it pretty professional.”
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Myers isn’t planning to don a costume this Oct. 31, but he did once pay tribute to Michael on Halloween a couple years ago, when he dressed as the masked maniac at a country club, where he had been asked to play piano for a party that evening.
Myers, who used to play in a band and now mostly plays music for his kids, says his wife floated the idea of dressing up as the Halloween character that night, which he had never done before.
“When they introduced the piano player as Michael Myers, nobody knew,” he says, “but I knew.”