As Myrtle Beach enters the new year, the city officially implemented 5% pay raises for two top-earning city officials.
Myrtle Beach’s city manager and city attorney are paid more than other top-ranking city officials, as well as others in the same positions for some larger South Carolina cities.
Last fiscal year, before the salary increases, city manager Jonathan “Fox” Simons’ annual salary was $278,262 and city attorney William Bryan Jr.’s annual salary was $203,320. By comparison, Police Chief Amy Prock’s annual salary was $188,032 and Fire Chief Paramedic Thomas Gwyer’s salary was $187,512 in the same time period. On the state level, South Carolina Governor Henry McMaster makes $106,078 annually.
On Jan. 1, cost of living pay increases went into effect for Bryan Jr. and Simons. With a 5% raise, Simons’ new salary amounts to about $292,175 yearly, and Bryan’s new salary amounts to $213,486 yearly.
However, because of the unusual implementation timeline, Simons and Bryan won’t receive the full increase for the fiscal year. With six months already passed, Simons will receive roughly a $6,957 increase over the next six months, and Bryan will receive about $5,083 more in the same period.
Although other city employees started receiving 5% raises after Myrtle Beach passed its roughly $360 million spending plan in June, City Council didn’t vote on Bryan and Simons’ raises until Dec. 9 – even though the increases were included in the spending plan.
Mayor Brenda Bethune, whose term ends this month, told The Sun News the raises should have been approved when Simons and Bryan’s contracts were reinstated. According to both Bethune and Councilman Mike Chestnut, the raises “fell through the cracks.”
“Perhaps we assumed that it was automatically done for them, as it was for the other employees and management personnel, but it was not, so when that was realized, we wanted to take care of it and get it done before the end of the year,” Bethune said.
Chestnut told The Sun News more bluntly of the vote to approve the raises, “I thought we did, and we didn’t.”
This fiscal year the city manager won’t collect the full $292,175 and the city attorney won’t receive the $213,486 total compensation, the salaries stand out among the top payouts for city officials.
But salary records for other South Carolina municipalities that use the same council-manager system as Myrtle Beach show that the positions are highly compensated across the state.
The Sun News submitted Freedom of Information Act requests for other council-manager cities to compare city manager and city attorney salaries. Here’s what they revealed.
Columbia
With an official population count of around 136,630 in the last census, Columbia is one of the largest cities in South Carolina. The capital city’s attorney is less compensated than Simons, with an annual salary of roughly $254,329, according to publicly available records. The city attorney also receives a lower salary than Bryan, making about $184,501 this year.
Rock Hill
The city of Rock Hill, which had a population of approximately 74,370 in 2020, had the highest city manager salary of the municipalities examined by The Sun News. While the city manager is paid $323,669, the city attorney isn’t paid a salary because they aren’t a city employee, the city said.
Greenville
The city of Greenville outspends Myrtle Beach on salaries for both the city manager and city attorney, according to the city. With a population of 70,720 at the last official count, Greenville pays the city manager $304,762 and the city attorney about $235,061 annually, the city revealed.
Sumter
According to a city representative, Sumter’s general counsel is compensated on an hourly basis, and the hours worked vary month to month. The city manager, however, receives an annual salary lower than Myrtle Beach’s, according to the city. The city of Sumter, which has a census population around 43,460, compensates its city manager with $273,095 a year.
Florence
With an official population of roughly 39,900 in 2020, Florence’s year-round population was close to Myrtle Beach’s census population of approximately 35,680. According to the city, Florence pays its city manager less than Myrtle Beach, about $234,000 annually, and doesn’t have a city attorney on staff.