STONEHAM, Mass. (WBZ NewsRadio) — A library has existed in Stoneham, in one form or another, for more than 300 years. That could all change in July. After an eighth failed proposal to raise property taxes past state limits, the town’s dire budget deficit has put civic mainstays like the library, the senior center, and the rec center in the crosshairs.
Hitting the Financial Wall
The problem boils down to money. Town officials had pinned their hopes on fixing longstanding budget shortfalls by using a Prop 2 ½ override earlier this month, worth $14.6 million. Prop 2 ½ is a state ballot measure passed in 1980 that caps the amount towns and cities can raise property taxes at 2.5% every year. The measure to raise property taxes failed by just 511 votes.
The no vote meant the town had to consider its nuclear worst-case scenario: drastic cuts to key town departments. At a meeting April 3, Michael Memmolo, chair of the Finance & Advisory Board, recommended gutting the library, recreation department, Council on Aging, and all traffic directors, zeroing out their budgets. He advised that the money be directed to Stoneham schools instead, to help keep them afloat and accredited.
The recommendations were met with dismay – even outrage – from some members of the board, including Joseph Joffe, who also recognized that the town was between a rock and a hard place.
“It’s utterly ridiculous, the position we’re in here,” he said at the time, cradling his head in his hands. “We’re not talking about cutting to the bone anymore. We’ve cut through the bone! The bone is gone, the limbs are gone. We’re talking about cutting the body in half!” he said.
Public, and Private, Dismay
“The impact would be devastating, frankly,” Library Assistant Director Lily Mysona told WBZ NewsRadio “We were expecting a $50,000 budget cut.”
Librarians at the Stoneham Public Library have taken the extraordinary step of mounting their own public campaign to keep their doors open, as the town openly mulls whether to shutter the library altogether. A bright scarlet banner across the library website reads “The Stoneham Public Library closing for good?” and directs readers to emails for the town administrator and select board.
Eighteen library staffers would be laid off if the town goes through with closing the library, which would take effect at the start of the new fiscal year in July. But the library staffers warn that it is much more than their own jobs on the chopping block.
For one, Mysona said, residents in Stoneham would not only be library-less, but they could be barred from borrowing at most other libraries in the state as well. That’s because public libraries in Massachusetts belong to the Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners, which certifies each town library as having spent enough to be included in the system. In this case, Stoneham would be joining a tiny handful of communities in the state without a certified library. A spokesperson for the MBLC said that meant virtually no other libraries in the state would need to lend to Stoneham residents, and that most would likely choose not to.
Mysona said reaction to the idea has been abjectly terrible, adding that it seems many people did not think a total library cut was on the table when the override was up for a vote – and neither did the librarians.
“From the public, we’ve seen horror, anger, sadness,” she said. “From little kids to the elderly, this is not something they want to see happen. Libraries are truly the last third space in our society where you can go and not be expected to perform, work, or spend.”
She pointed to the many services the library provides outside of books, from children’s programs that take the place of daycare, to internet access for those who can’t afford it, to simply giving people a place to meet.
Administrative Response and What’s Next
In response to WBZ NewsRadio, Town Administrator Dennis Sheehan said that “there has been no determination made on the future of the Stoneham Public Library… the constraints of Proposition 2 ½ frequently creates debates about ongoing and future priorities with limited financial resources and that community dialogue will move forward in the days and weeks ahead.”
Several members of the Stoneham select board voiced support on Tuesday evening for another override vote now that the library issue and several others are fully part of the public consciousness. But with the annual town meeting in May, and the fiscal year beginning on July 1, time is running short.
WBZ NewsRadio's Chaiel Schaffel (@CSchaffelWBZ) reports.