Olusoji Apampa opens BEHIND THE BOARDROOM DOOR, his new Proshare column on governance as it is practised, not as it is preached, with a response to advice heard at the Chartered Institute of Directors Nigeria’s 2026 Annual Directors’ Conference in Lagos. The advice held that directors should approve no artificial intelligence (AI) proposal until they fully understand what the technology is and what it will do.
Apampa sets that position against the CIoD’s State of Corporate Governance Report for January to June 2026, which he cites as showing that 66% of directors use AI tools while only 22% of organisations have formal AI governance and oversight frameworks. He reads board surveys by Deloitte and Protiviti as pointing in the same direction, and he notes that self-reported data do not establish cause and effect.
He accepts that the risks are real and cites the N555.8 million fine the Nigeria Data Protection Commission imposed on Fidelity Bank in August 2024, a finding the bank disputed. His case is that boards apply a full-comprehension test to no other technical matter, from expected-credit-loss models to actuarial valuations, and that directors meet their duty by relying on competent advice and testing it. He adds that the most cited AI board appointment, at Abu Dhabi’s International Holding Company, is a non-voting observer, leaving accountability with human directors.
The column closes with five steps for the next board meeting, covering an AI register, risk tiering, reversible pilots, a committee mandate and a ninety-day literacy commitment.
Two-thirds of Nigerian directors already use AI tools, yet barely one organisation in five has a framework to govern them. Telling boards to approve nothing until they fully understand AI will not close that gap. It will only move the AI out of the board’s sight.
The Paper on the Board Table
Imagine yourself at the board table. Management brings a paper proposing an AI model to screen loan applications, a chatbot to handle customer complaints, or software that drafts the board pack itself. The business case is strong, and the vendor’s slides are glossy. You do not fully understand how the thing reaches its answers. Do you approve it, or do you wait until you do?
That was the debate at the first plenary on the second day of the Chartered Institute of Directors’ annual conference in Lagos on 11 November. Some in the room were even weighing the idea of an AI director. Then came advice that stopped me in my tracks, namely that until directors fully understand what AI is, and what it will do in what they are approving, nothing should be approved. Some heads nodded. Many more looked like people standing at a crossroads, afraid of the road in front of them.
The Elder in the Market
Shakespeare gave us the most famous dithering in literature. “To be, or not to be” is Hamlet weighing action against delay, and his delay cost almost everyone in the play their lives. Our elders put it more practically in the proverb “Àgbà kì í wà l??jà, kí orí ?m? tuntun w??”, meaning an elder does not sit in the market and let the newborn’s head hang askew when backed by the mother.
The elder’s job is to be present and to make that presence count. Directors are the elders of the company. A board that freezes has not stayed in the market. It has left it.
What the Survey Data Show
And the AI is already in the market. The CIoD’s own State of Corporate Governance Report for January to June 2026 found that 66% of directors now use AI tools in their work, while only 22% of organisations have formal AI governance and oversight frameworks. The global picture is similar. In Deloitte’s 2025 survey of 695 board members and executives across 56 countries, 66% said their boards did not know enough about AI, and 31% said it was not on the board agenda at all. Protiviti’s 2026 survey of 772 directors and executives found that 63% of organisations reporting high returns from AI discuss it at every board meeting, against just 13% of those with low returns.
These are survey numbers, and self-reported ones. We do not know how many of that 66% are pasting confidential board papers into free public chatbots, which is a governance problem of its own. Nor does the Protiviti gap prove that talking about AI causes returns. But the direction is clear. The real gap is not between AI and no AI. It is between AI that is governed and AI that is not.
The Risks Behind the Caution
To be fair to the cautious adviser, the risks are real. In August 2024 the Nigeria Data Protection Commission fined Fidelity Bank N555.8 million, about 0.1% of its 2023 gross revenue, for processing personal data without informed consent. The bank disputed the finding.
The Commission says penalties can reach 2% of an organisation’s gross earnings. That case had nothing to do with AI. Now imagine the same lapse automated across a million customer records in an afternoon. A director who waves through a system nobody understands is not brave. He is exposed.
The Standard Directors Already Apply
But “approve nothing until you fully understand it” is a test no board applies to anything else. How many directors could rebuild their bank’s IFRS 9 expected-credit-loss model, their insurer’s actuarial valuation or their treasury’s hedging strategy? We approve them anyway. Directors have never been required to be engineers; they are required to rely on competent advice and to test it.
The Australian Institute of Company Directors puts it plainly, holding that directors may rely on management and advisers, but must critically assess that advice and bring their own judgement to bear. The standard is to understand enough to ask the right questions, not enough to write the code. Anything stricter is a ‘comprehension veto’, and it simply hands the decision to whoever is willing to use the tools without asking.
The Limits of an AI Director
As for the AI director, look closely at the example most often cited. In 2024 Abu Dhabi’s International Holding Company, the UAE’s largest listed firm, gave an AI called ‘Aiden Insight’ a seat at its board table, as a non-voting observer. Even there, the machine was not given a vote. It cannot owe a fiduciary duty. It cannot be sued, sanctioned or removed by shareholders. Accountability stays with the humans around the table.
Five Steps for the Next Board Meeting
So what should a director do at the next board meeting?
Closing Thoughts
Doing nothing is not an option; it only means the AI arrives through the side door, ungoverned. Rushing in is not an option either. The question before Nigerian boards is not whether to approve. It is on what terms. Hamlet’s tragedy was not that he thought too much. It was that he acted too late, and without a plan. The elder does not flee the market. She stays, and she keeps the newborn’s head straight.
About the Author
Olusoji Apampa is the Chief Executive Officer of ANNALYXX Global Ltd, developer of GovernLens, co-founder of The Integrity Organisation, and Chairman of Prominent Securities Ltd. Email: [email protected]
DISCLAIMER:
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Proshare, its management or affiliates. The article is published for public-policy discussion and general information. References to governance, institutional performance or economic outcomes should not be interpreted as investment, legal or professional advice. Readers should undertake an independent assessment before acting on any matter discussed. See our Terms of Use. For more information, visit www.proshare.coor contact [email protected]and
Proshare Nigeria Limited is an independent capital market intelligence and financial research platform.
to our market intelligence notes for updates. Thank you.