Steven Vernon Bixby, the Abbeville County man sentenced to death for the 2003 killings of two law enforcement officers, is asking the South Carolina Supreme Court to temporarily halt the next step toward his execution while his attorneys work on additional legal challenges.
In a motion filed Nov. 4, Bixby’s attorneys asked the state’s high court to hold the issuance of an execution notice in abeyance, arguing they need time to seek review from the U.S. Supreme Court and continue litigation challenging South Carolina’s execution procedures.
The request comes after the South Carolina Supreme Court denied a petition for rehearing in Bixby’s competency-to-be-executed case, clearing one of the final legal hurdles in the state’s effort to carry out his death sentence.
However, attorneys from the South Carolina Attorney General‘s Office argue no further delay is warranted and say state law requires the execution process to move forward now that judicial review has concluded.
Who is Steven Bixby?
According to previous Greenville News reporting, Bixby was convicted and sentenced to death for killing Abbeville County Sheriff’s Deputy Danny Wilson and Magistrate’s Constable Donnie Ouzts on Dec. 8, 2003.
During the encounter, Bixby opened fire, killing both officers. Greenville News previously reported that Bixby later told investigators he had anticipated law enforcement’s arrival and had prepared for a violent confrontation.
Bixby has spent more than two decades on South Carolina’s death row while pursuing a series of appeals in state and federal court. Those challenges have included claims involving intellectual disability, mental illness and competency to be executed.
Defense seeks more time
Bixby is represented by David Weiss and Gretchen Swift of the Capital Habeas Unit for the Fourth Circuit, a federal public defender office that handles death penalty appeals, along with Greenville attorney Joshua Snow Kendrick.
In the latest filing, Bixby’s attorneys argue they should be allowed to seek review from the nation’s highest court before an execution date is set. They contend constitutional questions remain following the South Carolina Supreme Court’s handling of his competency challenge.
The defense also points to a newly filed lawsuit against the South Carolina Department of Corrections challenging the legality of the state’s execution protocols and argues those issues should be resolved before the execution process proceeds.
Attorneys further noted that an execution date could fall during the holiday season if a notice is issued immediately, citing a 2024 order in which the Supreme Court delayed execution notices for several inmates until after the holidays.
As an alternative to a longer delay, Bixby’s attorneys asked the court to postpone issuance of an execution notice until Jan. 8, 2027.
State says appeals have run their course
The Attorney General’s Office urged the court to deny the request, arguing Bixby has already received nearly 20 years of judicial review through direct appeals, state post-conviction proceedings, federal habeas litigation and competency hearings.
State attorneys contend South Carolina law requires the clerk of the Supreme Court to issue an execution notice once appellate review is complete and characterize the action as a mandatory administrative duty rather than a discretionary decision.
Prosecutors also argue Bixby’s separate lawsuit challenging execution protocols is unrelated to his competency case and should not serve as grounds for delaying enforcement of his sentence.
The state additionally rejected the defense’s holiday-season argument, saying the court’s 2024 decision occurred under unique circumstances as South Carolina resumed executions following years of legal disputes over execution methods.
What happens next?
The South Carolina Supreme Court will decide whether to grant Bixby’s request for additional time or allow the execution-notice process to proceed.
If the court denies the motion, an execution notice could be issued in the coming days, beginning the process that would lead to South Carolina’s next scheduled execution. If the court grants the request, Bixby would receive additional time to pursue review before the U.S. Supreme Court and continue litigation involving the state’s execution procedures.
Public Safety Reporter Terry Benjamin can be reached at [email protected]
This article originally appeared on Greenville News: SC death row inmate Steven Bixby seeks delay in execution process
Reporting by Terry Benjamin II, Greenville News / Greenville News
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect