WASHINGTON COUNTY, Ohio — A report compiled for Buckeye Environmental Network found serious issues with the way Ohio documents and responds to oil and gas incidents — an issue compounded by a steady increase in the number of incidents in the last decade.
In 2015, there were 103 oil and gas incidents per year in Ohio according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR). By 2025, that number ballooned to 268 per year, FracTracker Alliance’s analysis found.
In those 10 years, the state recorded 2,529 oil and gas incidents. However, FracTracker’s analysis found it was “difficult to determine what happened, the severity of the incident and how it was resolved.”
“Ohio is recording more oil and gas incidents, but the records still make it too hard to tell how serious many were and what, if anything, happened afterward,” Gwen Klenke, the report’s author, said. “ODNR needs more inspectors, clearer incident records, and enforcement of the laws already on the books.”
Similarly, FracTracker found “a lack of consistency in inspections, enforcement and follow-up” when wells have incidents or violations, though this is likely because ODNR’s inspection capacity is “insufficient for consistent and meaningful oversight.”
While Ohio has 96,000 oil and gas wells, ODNR has roughly 25 inspectors who are responsible for monitoring them.
FracTracker estimates visiting each active well once would require an average of 664 workdays per inspector — more than two-and-a-half working years between visits.
Of particular concern to Buckeye Environmental Network and FracTracker is ODNR’s enforcement process, which “seeks to return the regulated community to compliance at the lowest level of enforcement possible.”
Buckeye Environmental Network has spent years gathering information about oil and gas incidents throughout Ohio and ODNR’s response to them, Bev Reed, Appalachian organizer at Buckeye Environmental Network, explained.
However, it was thanks to Buckeye Environmental Network’s partnership with FracTracker that a thorough analysis of this data was performed, Reed continued.
“I think where Buckeye Environmental Network came in was taking the real world examples of ODNR's lack of follow through with violations and issues with oil and gas wells and injection wells,” Reed said. “We're a good team because there's no other group in Ohio that does what we do on the ground, working with people that are impacted directly.”
Reed argues that, because of ODNR’s approach to regulating the oil and gas industry, there is a lack of follow through when responding to violations and issues with oil and gas wells and injection wells.
“All these wells around Marietta, some of them have been inspected over 20 times, and there’s still no follow through on the violations,” Reed said. “That's only a snapshot in one little area. How big is this problem across the state? Nobody knows. This report just corroborated what we are already finding in real-life.”
Bob Wilson, an oil and gas producer in Washington County, complained to ODNR about brine migration from injection wells in the area impacting his wells. However, Wilson alleges he was ignored by ODNR when he did so.
“I started losing wells, three or four a week. I called ODNR and told them I believed injection water was infiltrating my wells,” Wilson said. “They told me that wasn't possible and they hung up.”
In July 2026, four injection wells in Washington County voluntarily ceased operations after ODNR’s Division of Oil and Gas Resources Management notified their owners of the impact their injection wells were having on neighboring oil and natural gas wells.
However, a 2020 study by ODNR already confirmed brine migration from Redbird #4, one of the four injection wells that ceased operations.
Despite this, the well continued operating for another six years after a brief hiatus. The only changes made at Redbird #4 were that ODNR required injections into a different rock formation and depth.
Redbird #4 and other incidents involving leaky wells are illustrative of the difficulties ODNR has in balancing its regulatory duties with the demands of Ohio’s state government, which views oil and gas as an economic boon to the state, Roxanne Groff, an advisory board member at Buckeye Environmental Network, argued.
“We’re concerned about what is happening to communities and we have an enforcement agency that just says, ‘Well, we're just doing what we're told. We're just doing what the lawmakers have told us to do,’” Groff said. “But, you also have to enforce the laws and have rules and laws that protect the people, not just the industry.”