EAST HAMPTON — For some, going into business with a sibling would be a nightmare. But it was always the goal for Eugene and Samuel Valentin.
The brothers behind Two Brothers Cafe have worked in restaurants since they were teenagers. Eugene Valentin got his start learning to make bread when he was only 12, while his brother, Samuel, started as a busboy at 17, and worked his way up to a managerial position at fast food restaurants such as Burger King and Wendy’s.
Both knew they didn’t want to work for other people forever. But they thought their first business endeavor might be property management. That is, until last year, when Eugene Valentin saw an ad for restaurant equipment being sold by the owner of The Sleepy Rooster Cafe, the breakfast joint that previously occupied the space on Route 66 in the Cobalt section of town.
Like Two Brothers, The Sleepy Rooster was run by two sisters.
Eugene Valentine, who also operates a hot dog cart, decided to buy some of the pieces for sale. When he showed up, he asked about the space. The Sleepy Rooster proprietor offered it to him pending the building owner’s blessing.
“My brother was with me, and we looked at each other (and knew),” Eugene Valentin said. “We were both burnt out working for someone else, so we took this opportunity and ran with it.”
“(We wanted) to serve people and to bring good food to town,” added Samuel Valentin. “That was our goal, to bring satisfaction to the people of town.”
After three months of prepping, the co-owners opened Two Brothers Cafe Aug. 18, 2021, with Eugene Valentin as chef and Samuel Valentin as manager. It is painted pink inside and out.
“I worked with him before, and it was good back then; and over here, same thing,” said Samuel Valentin. “He has a lot of knowledge of the kitchen and he's taught me a lot. We share a little bit of what he knows and what I know. We make it work, always.”
So far business has been good, said Samuel Valentine, with an average of 70 to 150 customers stopping by on an average day — ranging from people on their morning commute to those passing through the area on their way to nearby towns.
The brothers said the cafe’s location, by a traffic light off Route 66/East High Street, lends itself to drawing in customers who see their sign from the road.
“It's honestly been a good year and a half for us,” Sameul Valentin added. “It’s a lot more work working for yourself, but it’s completely worth it.”
The menu at Two Brothers focuses on breakfast and lunch offerings, along with occasional specials, including monthly pop-up dinner events such as Taco Tuesday nights, and Latin night where the two offer food inspired by their Puerto Rican roots.
“We keep it interesting so we don’t fall into the same,” Eugene Valentin said. “We try to bring some Latin flavor here to Cobalt.”
The eatery’s daily fare consists of standard breakfast and lunch dishes, including waffles, pancakes, a variety of wraps and club sandwiches, plus plain, asiago, sesame, everything and cinnamon raisin bagels made locally in North Windham, and delivered fresh every Tuesday and Thursday.
Eugene Valentin also tapped into his culinary skills from his previous restaurant jobs to craft some special offerings, including the Two Brothers bagel (a toasted bagel of choice with spinach, tomatoes, avocado, bacon, cream cheese, smoked salmon and red onions), and the Two Brothers omelet made with hamburger, avocado, tomato, bacon, gorgonzola, and house sauce and served with of potatoes and toast.
For lunch, there’s the Two Brothers burger, a half-pound of meat topped with bacon, avocado, gorgonzola, lettuce, tomatoes and house sauce. As for a pick-me-up, visitors can try the Two Brothers, a 24-ounce coffee with caramel, chocolate, white chocolate, cinnamon sugar and whipped cream.
The cafe only offers takeout since the building cannot accommodate indoor dining, but, Eugene Valentin said, they plan to find a place where they can set up a dining room and expand while ideally staying in the Cobalt area and on Route 66, which draws in a lot of traffic.
“We just fell in love with this little spot,” he said. “There’s no competition.”
For information, navigate to twobrotherscafe.square.site.
Dec 13, 2022|Updated Dec 14, 2022 10:07 a.m.
Erin Kayata was formerly a reporter with Hearst Connecticut Media Group. She was most recently the city hall reporter for the Norwalk Hour. She previously covered education for the Stamford Advocate. Erin got her start as a Hearst fellow covering Darien and New Canaan. She previously worked at the Boston Globe as part of its co-op program. Erin grew up in southeastern Massachusetts and graduated from Emerson College with a degree in journalism.