CORDOVA, Tenn. — Residents in the Cordova neighborhood of Countrywood have been on a rocky road with the city of Memphis.
They want help getting their street repaired, but said the city, county, and even the apartment complex that uses the road have washed their hands of the responsibility.
WREG investigator April Thompson shows why things are at a stalemate and what it could mean for others who find themselves in a similar bind.
Colonial Towers, a small Cordova community, is fighting a big problem.
“Let’s just do the right thing, right? Like, let’s just fix the holes,” said Lorri Schmitz, said a Cordova resident.
Schmitz moved to Cordova in 2011.
“It’s very quiet and a nice place to raise a family,” said Schmitz.
But over the last few years, she has been dodging potholes that cover the street she lives on.
“I mean as soon as you enter through the gate at the very end, you have to basically zigzag all the way down the street,” said Schmitz. “I’ve had my mailbox hit twice because people come on the left side so close to avoid the holes, and then I’ve had the fire hydrant hit once. So it’s a battle to get through this road.”
Schmitz said there was mention of a Homeowners Association when she moved in, but she later learned the HOA dissolved in the 1990s. And when it did, apparently all responsibilities went with it, including upkeep of the road.
They were left asking. Who can help?
“That’s a good question, because it’s hard to tell who’s responsible. If you look up the plat map of this road, it says Shelby County. When you call Shelby County, they say to call Memphis City. When you call Memphis City, they say to call Shelby County,” said Schmitz.
The plat map also has an owner’s certificate signed in 1982, designating the streets, right-of-way, and grant of easements to public use.
But we are told that it may or may not be accepted by a city or county as grounds for taking over maintenance.
“So it’s just getting the run around constantly,” said Schmitz.
Colonial Towers Drive sits inside the Countrywood neighborhood. We reached out to the Countrywood Homeowners’ Association about what help they could offer the residents.
The HOA President said that while the street is within Countrywood, the HOA doesn’t have any obligation or resources to repair a road that was allowed to go into disrepair.
WREG reached out to the City of Memphis; they sent us a parcel map showing the road is private.
The city said, “Engineering reviewed the records and confirmed the roadway is private, with no documentation formally dedicating it as a public street. The Colonial Villas development plan also identifies it as a private drive. The 311 request ( made by the residents) was closed because pothole repairs on private roads fall outside Public Works’ maintenance.”
Attorney Michael Working says the homeowners’ best bet is unifying, either by hiring an attorney or appealing to the city council for the city to agree to take over the street.
“It’s probably cheaper to hire one attorney that can represent your class in a dispute with the city to try to find some sort of mutual agreement that works out best for everyone, both the neighborhood and the public,” said Working.
Access Easement laws say that if a person or business benefits from an easement or road, they should contribute to the cost of maintaining the easement.
But even that has gray areas.
The bottom line, for anyone in an HOA or considering buying in an HOA neighborhood, Working said, is to be familiar with the rules on the front end, including what happens if an HOA dissolves.
And know what your responsibility will be as a member, including dues and special assessments for things like roads.
For homeowners on Colonial Towers Drive, it means unifying to make changes after things were changed on them.
“And we pay city and county taxes, and we have to pay for our street?” said Schmitz. “That’s all I’m looking for, some answers and what to do next here.”
The residents also said they are paying monthly for street lights that haven’t been working. They assumed that meant the city was responsible for the street.
But the city told WREG that all residents are charged a street light fee, whether they live on a private street or not.
The street is also used by a nearby apartment complex as their only access road.
WREG also asked apartment managers about repairing the road. They said they want it fixed too, but it’s not their responsibility.