In a letter to PHMSA, Fitzpatrick writes that "the public has repeatedly been met with half-answers, or worse, no answers at all."
Patch Staff
UPPER MAKEFIELD, PA — U.S. Congressman Brian Fitzpatrick is again calling on the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) to shutdown the Sunoco Pipeline running through Bucks County until all corrective measures are fully implemented and the safety of the pipeline is unequivocally confirmed.
In late January, Energy Transfer, which operates the pipeline for Sunoco, confirmed a leak that contaminated the groundwater and a number of residential wells with jet fuel in the Mt. Eyre Manor neighborhood.
After meeting with impacted residents from the Mt. Eyre Manor community, the Bucks County congressman fired off a letter on Friday to Ben Kochman, the acting administrator of PHMSA, outlining the concerns of residents.
“The public has repeatedly been met with half-answers, or worse, no answers at all,” he wrote. “My constituents have asked for full transparency and accountability. I believe the residents of our community deserve nothing less.
“The impact of this leak on our community cannot be overstated. Families are now dependent on bottled water as their primary source of drinking water, many have unknowingly consumed contaminated water, and property values have been compromised,” he continued.
Find out what's happening in Newtownfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
“Perhaps most profoundly, our residents are living in a constant state of fear and uncertainty, questioning whether they can ever trust their environment again.”
Joining the congressman in calling for a shutdown of the pipeline are U.S. Senator John Fetterman, the Bucks County Commissioners, State Senator Steve Santarsiero and State Rep. Perry Warren who represent the township in Washington, Harrisburg and Bucks County. The Upper Makefield Board of Supervisors have also asked that the line be temporarily shutdown.
“The Constitution of our Commonwealth guarantees every citizen the right to clean air, pure water, and the protection of our environment for future generations. Allowing a faulty pipeline - one with a documented history of leaks - to continue operating directly violates these fundamental rights and furtherjeopardizes the health and safety of our community,” said Fitzpatrick. “We cannot, and must not, stand idly by as these rights are trampled upon.”
In his letter, Fitzpatrick said the “ongoing situation has left our residents feeling unsafe and uncertain in their own homes. No family should ever have to question their safety or the quality of their water, yet that is the painful reality we face today.”
Fitzpatrick said while the February 13, 2025, Notice of Proposed Safety Order is a step toward addressing both immediate and long-term solutions, he expressed “deep concern” that the proposed actions may not go far enough to ensure the safety and well-being of the community.
Fitzpatrick blasted Energy Transfer's response to PHMSA's Safety Order, which he said “oversteps its bounds” and is “not only insensitive to the residents directly affected but also dismissive of the broader public concern.”
At three public meetings with Sunoco and Energy Transfer officials residents have contended that the leak started 16 months earlier. Sunoco and Energy Transfer have said there is insufficient evidence to support the claim.
“As both the preliminary report and Sunoco's own response indicate, the September 2023 odor complaint is a strong indication that the leak began around that time,” Fitzpatrick writes in his letter to the Pipeline Administration. “Furthermore, as confirmed by DEP during the February 27 town hall, if they had known then what they know now, it would have been ‘insane’ to miss such a significant issue.
“I agree with DEP's assessment and must remind both PHMSA and Sunoco that the leak was only detected due to a private citizen conducting an independent test,” wrote Fitzpatrick to the Pipeline Administration.
Fitzpatrick added that while Sunoco acknowledged taking some corrective actions, “they fail to provide sufficient proof that these actions have been adequate to restore public confidence. Simply put, the community remains unconvinced that the pipeline is safe. If Sunoco genuinely wishes to regain the trust of the community, I believe they must take the responsible step of temporarily shutting down the pipeline until all corrective measures are fully implemented and the safety of the pipeline is unequivocally confirmed.
Fitzpatrick said Sunoco's claim that there is no sufficient evidence to determine how long the pipeline had been leaking “is not only tone-deaf but also disregards the fact that the leak was detected by a private citizen conducting their own test. If Sunoco had been monitoring the pipeline properly, I believe it would not have taken 10 days to confirm the existence of a leak. The failure to detect this issue internally raises serious concerns about Sunoco's ability to ensure the safety of the pipeline going forward.”
Fitzpatrick concludes his letter by writing, “I trust that these comments will receive full and fair consideration and if applicable, I request that this letter be submitted as part of the record, as well as made available to all interested parties.”
Upper Makefield will hold its next public meeting and update with Sunoco, the state Department of Environmental Protection and the U.S. Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration on Tuesday, March 11 beginning at 7:30 p.m. at The Crossing Church, 1895 Wrightstown Road, Washington Crossing.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.