The Blue Jackets have gotten the NHL’s full attention by pushing for a playoff spot against long odds, but they’re finding out why it’s so difficult to earn a postseason ticket.
There are no free passes to the Stanley Cup Playoffs, even for heartwarming stories, and the Jackets must fare better in their final 18 games than they did during a four-game road trip that concluded Tuesday night with a 5-3 loss to the New Jersey Devils.
After winning four straight coming out of the league's break for the 4 Nations Face-Off in February, they’ve gone 1-3-0 since defeating the Detroit Red Wings at Ohio Stadium. The only win was a 7-3 blowout of the New York Rangers on Sunday at Madison Square Garden, where the playoff-chasing hosts forgot to play defense.
The Tampa Bay Lightning, Florida Panthers and Devils didn’t have that issue against the Blue Jackets.
Here are four takeaways from a frustrating night in New Jersey:
Thanks to the Winnipeg Jets’ 2-1 victory over the Rangers on Tuesday night in Winnipeg, the Blue Jackets retained the second wild card spot in the Eastern Conference.
Had the Rangers won, they would’ve tied the Jackets at 70 points and bumped them out of a playoff spot based on the NHL’s standings tiebreaker rules. Instead, the Montreal Canadiens and Rangers are now tied at 68 points and trail Columbus by two points.
The Blue Jackets, meanwhile, lost ground to both the Devils within the Metropolitan Division and Ottawa Senators in the East’s wild card hunt. Ottawa’s victory over the Philadelphia Flyers on Tuesday pushed them three points ahead of the Jackets for the first wild card spot.
Columbus Blue Jackets struggle against New Jersey Devils' defensive intensity
The Devils are playing without injured stars Jack Hughes and Dougie Hamilton, but they’re still capable of putting together dominant stretches of puck possession. They did it sporadically against the Blue Jackets, including a three-goal first period aided by a power play and two fortunate bounces.
New Jersey scored two opportunistic goals to build a 3-0 lead after Nico Hischier’s early goal to cap a power play, but luck had nothing to do with the Devils’ defensive pressure making life miserable for the overwhelmed Blue Jackets. Just like it was for the Jackets in Tampa and Sunrise, Florida, they could barely complete a pass for most of the first period in New Jersey.
The neutral zone was a minefield, the offensive zone was mostly closed for business and the Devils literally skated circles around the Blue Jackets’ zone. It was a different story in the second period, but not enough for a full comeback.
The Blue Jackets were outshot for the seventh time in the past eight games (25-20) and have been outshot in 15 of the past 20. Their 10-8-2 record in that span is remarkable and, most likely, not sustainable for much longer.
Mathieu Olivier's offensive surge continues in elevated top-six role for Columbus Blue Jackets
Mathieu Olivier has scored the bulk of his 15 goals this season in two stretches. The first solidified his bump up to the third line for most of the season, while the second may keep the Jackets’ popular power forward in a top-six role.
After adding two points on a goal and assist Sunday against the Rangers, Olivier added two goals in New Jersey to push his career-high for a single season to 15.
That’s 10 more than his prior career-high of five goals each of the past two years with the Blue Jackets, who will gladly take the production while continuing to depend on Olivier’s size, strength and fists to keep opposing players honest.
Columbus Blue Jackets sorely miss Sean Monahan on power plays
The Blue Jackets’ success on power plays has nose-dived since losing Sean Monahan to a wrist injury Jan. 7. They’re clicking at just 10% in 23 games since Monahan left the lineup, which ranks 31st out of 32 teams in that span.
Monahan is the bumper who typically lines up between the circles in a 1-3-1 power play setup. He also took key faceoffs to start power plays and kept the puck inside the offensive zone by supporting teammates along the walls. Prior to his injury, Monahan helped boost the Blue Jackets’ power play into the 11th best in the league at 23.9% through the first 41 games.
After going 0 for 3 and struggling to get set up inside the Devils’ zone, the Blue Jackets went 0 for 10 on their road trip.
Columbus Blue Jackets goalie Elvis Merzlikins had another tough night in New Jersey
Prudential Center is a building that Blue Jackets goalie Elvis Merzlikins probably wouldn’t mind skipping.
Most of the five goals he allowed Tuesday weren’t primarily his fault, but getting tagged with five goals on 25 shots had to sting. That arena was also the site of a 7-1 loss to the Devils on Oct. 30, 2022.
Merzlikins has solid career numbers overall against New Jersey at 4-4-2 with a 3.16 goals-against average and .911 save percentage, but dropped to 1-2-2 in Newark, New Jersey with a 4.06 GAA and .897 save percentage at Prudential Center.
[email protected]
@BrianHedger.bsky.social
Get more on the Columbus Blue Jackets with our Cannon Fodder podcast