The fourth-seeded Hightstown High School softball team shocked top-seeded and state No. 5 Steinert, 2-1, in the Colonial Valley Conference semifinal on Monday night.
But that epic win only put the Rams in the final 24 hours later.
On Tuesday night, the Rams made sure their accomplishment a night earlier didn’t go for naught, backing up the upset with a 4-0, nine-inning win over third-seeded Notre Dame to win what is believed to be the program’s first-ever CVC title. Even the 2019 Group 4 state champs didn’t win the county crown.
Complete Box Score »
“If they did it, it hasn’t been for a very long time, but I couldn’t find it anywhere so I guess we’re the first,” said first-year coach Lauren Brown. “It means a lot to the girls, means a lot to me. This is the biggest game I’ve ever played or coached in.
“It was our goal to be as successful as the (2019) team that won states. We knew we had talented kids coming into the season, and we could capitalize if we stayed focused, so this was really big for us. Last night felt like the championship, but this game was far more important.”
Senior pitcher Kady Olsen capped a tremendous tournament with a thorough performance against the Irish. She set down the first nine batters and finished with a two-hit shutout, striking out eight, including the final batter of the game.
She also provided the game-winning RBI in the top of the ninth. After the Rams loaded the bases with nobody out, Olsen lined a single into left field for the first run of the game.
“I just had one job,” said Olsen. “I just had to put it in play.”
Two batters later, Sofia Hulme singled to left to score one run and when the ball was misplayed, two more runners came around.
“Coming from the big win, our girls had such great energy,” said Olsen. “We knew they were a hard team, but we gave it all we got. My girls had my back in the field, and I just had to do my job and throw strikes and focus on myself. I have no words, really, we all played really well.”
Hightstown loaded the bases with nobody out in the sixth but didn’t score and left 12 runners on base, but in the ninth, the Rams started at the top of the lineup and delivered five hits in the frame. Seton Hall-bound Olivia Pignatello singled off Notre Dame pitcher Biance Pesce for her second hit to start the rally.
Olivia Werdon reached base all five times and Hayden Bustos and Lilly Peto each singled twice for the Rams.
“We worked really hard all season and put it all together collectively,” said Pignatello. “We had some big wins this year and carrying all that into this we knew we had a chance. For me and Kady being seniors, it means everything.”
The Irish threatened only twice, though the first time almost proved to be the game winner. With two on and two out in the fourth, Pesce hit a sinking liner to center but Haylie Bustos played it perfectly, coming in and making a diving catch to thwart the rally.
“We’ve made plays this whole tournament I’ve never seen my kids do before,” said Brown. “That saved us a couple runs. The momentum we got from that play carried on.”
Said Olsen: “That was insane, but off the bat I knew she had it.”
The Irish moved the potential winning run into scoring position in the seventh, but Olsen induced a harmless pop-up to send the game to extra innings.
The hard-throwing right-hander put together a huge tournament. She homered twice and knocked in all five runs in the quarterfinals against Allentown, fanned 13 Steinert batters in the semifinal and did it all in the championship game when she and the Rams refused to be denied.
“She’s something else and she’s just the rock of our team,” said Brown. “Her coming up in the ninth to get that first run was one of those moments that felt like the perfect storybook ending.”
Bill Evans can be reached at [email protected]. Follow him at @bybillevans.
The N.J. High School Sports newsletter is now appearing in mailboxes 5 days a week. Sign up now!
Follow us on social: Facebook | Instagram | X (formerly Twitter)