There is no fire sprinkler system at Spinning Elementary School in Puyallup.
Bricks in the wall of the mechanical room are crumbling. The building has old pipes, plumbing issues (they shut down the staff bathroom earlier this week) and a deteriorating roof.
The intercom system is faulty, and the clocks attached to the bell system don’t really work. Because they’re connected, the bells go off at the wrong times.
Most students eat lunch in their classrooms. There isn’t enough space in the cafeteria. Some of the tables in the lunchroom are makeshift folding tables. The gym is small and can accommodate half a basketball court.
Doing work on the building requires abatement. It has asbestos and galvanized pipes. The heating system is old and finicky. Some rooms are hot and others are cold.
“The building is at the end of its life,” Spinning Elementary School principal Sari Burnett told The News Tribune on Thursday. The building is from 1935, but there’s been a school on the land since 1891, Burnett said.
If the school district doesn’t get funding to rebuild the elementary school soon, district leaders say it’s one of the buildings they’d consider closing.
The district is asking voters to approve an $800 million bond on the Feb. 11 special election ballot that would rebuild Spinning, Waller Road Elementary and Mt. View Elementary. It would also build a new elementary school on land that the district owns above Emerald Ridge High School, and it would expand Emerald Ridge, Puyallup High School and Rogers High School.
The district has about 23,000 students across its 34 schools and expects its student body to grow by 1,000 students over the next 10 years. Right now it uses 221 portable classrooms.
Spinning has about 300 students. The rebuilt school would have double the square footage and would accommodate 500 students. If voters approve the bond, the soonest the school would open is September 2028.
Puyallup resident Ellen Aronson is part of the “yes” committee supporting the district’s bond proposal. She was also part of the district’s capital facilities advisory committee that put the bond proposal together, and she has two students in the district, a 15-year-old daughter and an 11-year-old son.
She said the condition of Waller Road Elementary is also dire.
Both schools might have to close in the next couple years if the bond doesn’t pass because the infrastructure needs of the buildings are so significant, she said. Instead, students would go to the district’s other local elementary schools, which don’t have classroom space to spare, she said.
“Puyallup is a growing community, and our schools are already kind of at the max,” Aronson said.
There isn’t a “no” campaign against the proposal that’s listed in the voters’ pamphlet.
District officials say the bond won’t increase the property tax rate. The bond on the ballot is $800 million, but some of that funding voters already approved.
Brady Martin, the district’s director of capital projects who gave The News Tribune a tour of Spinning, said the district would take $130 million of capital project levy funds that voters approved in February 2024 and essentially refinance it as part of the $800 million bond.
Voters last year agreed to a property-tax rate of $4.14 per $1,000 of assessed value ($36.25 per month for the owner of a $500,000 home) for a six-year $175 million capital levy. That rate takes effect this year. If voters pass the bond, they’d maintain that same property tax rate for 21 years.
Superintendent John Polm told The News Tribune the bond would help “address some challenges that the district has faced for years.”
He acknowledged that passing bonds right now isn’t easy. The last bond voters approved for the school district was 10 years ago, in 2015. A 2019 bond that would have expanded the high schools failed.
“Sixty percent is a very difficult threshold to meet,” he said.
There are legislative proposals in Olympia that would lower the 60 percent threshold, he said.
Puyallup High School has about 1,700 students, and its capacity is 1,250. If the bond passes, the renovations would increase the capacity to 1,800.
District officials say it’s short on classroom space, especially after the school closed its aging Library Science Building in 2023. It was built in 1962. Crews will demolish it this summer.
The closure meant students lost their library, science classrooms and art classrooms.
To make do, the district turned the staff lounge into an art classroom, but they had to pause the pottery program. They found a 500-square-foot space to turn into a mini library, where students can pick up books they request from other schools in the district.
Physics is one of Puyallup High School senior Akshaj Mukkollu’s favorite subjects, he told The News Tribune between classes Thursday. The 17-year-old hopes to study biomedical engineering in college.
He said there are three students in his advanced physics class, which is held at a table in the hallway. They don’t have classroom space. He misses doing physics labs.
Before the Library Science Building closed, he said one of his favorite labs involved tuning soda bottles into rockets. Students calculated the trajectory of where they expected the rockets to land. They still do small labs every now and then, he said, but it’s not the same.
“Now we just don’t have that much space,” he said.
The permitting to turn existing classrooms into science labs following the closure of the Library Science Building was complicated with the city and the health department, district officials said. That meant Mukkollu only did two labs during his chemistry class last year.
Besides having space for labs, having fewer portables would be another benefit if the bond passes, he said. His literature class is in a portable classroom this year.
“I know that’s something that people don’t often look forward to,” he said.
His brother is in eighth grade and will be going to Puyallup High School soon.
“It’s an old school, it’s got a lot of history, but that also has its limitations,” he said.
The 17-year-old emphasized that passing the bond won’t raise property taxes beyond the rate that voters passed last year.
“It doesn’t increase taxes, which is the biggest thing that I would want people to know,” he said.
Aronson said the “yes” campaign behind the Sumner-Bonney Lake School District bond that passed in November put an emphasis on reaching residents online. Puyallup’s campaign is emulating that, she said.
“We’re trying to really reach out via social media more than we have in the past,” she said, so that residents “know what’s at stake.”
She said the $4.14 rate is in the middle of the pack. It’s not the highest in Pierce County, and it’s not the lowest. She said that, if the bond doesn’t pass, it’s likely that the district would try again, and that rising costs mean there’s a good chance future proposals wouldn’t keep the tax rate the same.
“Every year that these projects get delayed, they’re just costing more and more,” she said. “... This is our chance. We can lock in the rate, sort of the most bang for our buck, the most efficient way to fund these important projects.”
Puyallup opened Dessie Evans Elementary School in 2019. It cost the district $52 million, Martin, the district’s director of capital projects, told The News Tribune. That same school, today, would cost more than $100 million to build, he said. Costs have gone up about 48 percent, he said, and keep going up 4.5 percent, year over year. Spinning, a smaller school than Dessie Evans, would cost $88 million to rebuild.
Washington state does not fund school construction, he said, but the state does provide some matching funds. If voters pass the $800 million proposal, the state would potentially chip in $152.9 million for capital projects, district officials say.
Martin said the district started with a list of $1.26 billion worth of projects, and that the capital facilities advisory committee whittled it down to put together the proposed bond.
The Puyallup community prides itself on having good schools, Aronson said. That reputation is part of why she bought a home here. She’s lived in Puyallup since 2007. If voters had approved past bonds, she said, her kids would probably be going to remodeled schools. Instead, she’s campaigning for a bond proposal that she hopes will help other families.
“It’s really important to me that I live in a place that is supportive of the school system,” she said.
She’s been checking each morning to see how many ballots have been returned. The 60 percent supermajority and the turnout threshold are going to be challenging to meet, she said.
In addition to passing by at least 60 percent, the measure requires at least 28,216 voters to cast ballots (40 percent of the voters in the last general election, which is a significantly higher bar to clear following a presidential election year).
Aronson is out waving signs to get support for the bond, which she said embarrasses her teenager a little bit.
“National politics is really overwhelming,” she said. “This feels like something tangible that I can do to impact my community in a positive way.”
The special election is Feb. 11. Ballots have to be postmarked by Feb. 11 or dropped in a ballot box by 8 p.m. that night.
Washington State
March 19, 2025 5:00 AM
World
March 16, 2025 2:11 PM
See all stories