The Castle Rock Town Council on Tuesday appointed an independent examiner to investigate allegations of misconduct against a councilmember following an official complaint filed with the town.
The council meeting became contentious as members lodged serious allegations against each other claiming past ethical misconduct.
Councilmembers unanimously selected Wynetta Massey, former Colorado Springs city attorney, to serve as the independent hearing examiner.
Massey helped create the Colorado Springs Ethics Commission and served as city attorney for 11 years, according to town staff.
In August, David Miles, a Castle Rock resident and member of the town’s Design Review Board, alleged that Councilmember Mark Davis attempted to trade a town policy decision for the withdrawal of a recall effort led by Miles.
Miles previously told The Denver Gazette the recall was driven by disagreements over Davis’ positions on growth and development in downtown Castle Rock, as well as his efforts to eliminate the Design Review Board, which reviews development applications for projects under 10,000 square feet.
During public comment at an August council meeting, Miles distributed copies of text messages to councilmembers and alleged Davis contacted both him and the father of another recall organizer after learning of the recall effort.
According to messages reviewed by The Denver Gazette and described by Miles during public comment, Davis sent Miles a text in August stating, “I’ll drop getting rid of the DRB if you pull the recall. Let me know by Monday morning 8 a.m.”
Miles characterized the message as an attempt to exchange an official policy position for the withdrawal of a lawful political action.
“That is quid pro quo,” Miles previously told The Denver Gazette. “I’ll do this for you if you do this for me.”
Miles also alleged that Davis contacted the father of another recall participant and discussed development-related matters before asking whether the recall effort could be withdrawn.
One text message reviewed by The Denver Gazette appears to show Davis stating, “I don’t mind playing hardball … It goes with the job.”
Another appears to show Davis asking the participant’s father, “Do you want to talk to your son … and ask him if he wants to pull back that recall?”
Following public comment at the August meeting, Councilmembers Ryan Hollingshead and Kevin Bracken, along with Mayor Jason Gray, voted in favor of censure, while Councilmembers Max Brooks, Tim Dietz and Mayor Pro Tem Laura Cavey voted against it.
Under the town code, when a formal complaint is filed, the council must appoint an independent hearing examiner to determine whether a violation of the town’s code of conduct occurred.
If the examiner determines that a violation occurred, the council may, by a two-thirds vote, impose penalties including a verbal admonition, written reprimand, censure or a fine.
Davis did not directly address the allegations during the August council meeting, when members voted on the censure proposal.
During Tuesday’s meeting, Dietz said an independent investigation would provide the council with valuable information.
“Now we see due process is actually happening,” Dietz said.
Brooks agreed, saying the town code established a clear process for handling formal complaints.
“I said at the time, and I’ll stand by it, that we needed to be able to consult with the town attorney, consult with the town manager, and understand what our own code is and what the process is,” Brooks said. “Those motions are appropriate only after we’ve gone through the process.”
The meeting grew contentious as council members exchanged additional allegations related to those who supported the censure effort.
Cavey alleged that Bracken had been asked to step down as mayor pro tem in late 2023. She alleged he attended meetings while impaired by alcohol and, at times, fell asleep at the dais.
“To protect Castle Rock from a public scandal, we allowed him to cite work issues and quietly resign,” Cavey said.
She also accused Bracken of starting an altercation with another board member in late 2025 while intoxicated.
Cavey further accused Gray of applying a double standard by supporting Davis’ censure while backing Bracken’s reinstatement as mayor pro tem.
“It clearly demonstrates Mayor Gray’s double standard: rules for thee, but not for me,” Cavey said.
Bracken vehemently denied the allegations.
He said that during that period he had been prescribed painkillers for a severe injury and voluntarily stepped down from the position due to responsibilities outside of the council.
“Don’t lie about me,” Bracken said. “I have a doctor’s letter, I have prescriptions, and I have all the information that you don’t have a right to question me on. You’re wrong. You’re vehemently wrong.”
Dietz also criticized Gray for supporting the August censure effort.
“Earlier on Aug. 18, we saw where Mark Davis was convicted, tried and sentenced. Jason Gray, you convicted Mark Davis, along with Councilmember Hollingshead and Councilmember Bracken,” Dietz said. “This is by far the worst thing I see happening in Castle Rock right now, and it’s giving us a black eye.”
The council ultimately approved Massey’s appointment to conduct an independent review of the allegations against Davis.