By Maddie Browning for Denverite
Greg Weadick has been cooking with foie gras since culinary school — and until recently, he made the controversial delicacy a part of the menu at Nocturne Jazz & Supper Club, where he is the executive chef.
“It was a foie gras macaron that had some Sauternes gelée,” he explained while taking a reporter on a tour of the chic restaurant on 27th Street in the River North district.
That item has now disappeared from the menu — a change Weadick made just before Denver voters decided to ban the sale of traditionally made foie gras within the city limits.
“So, it’s disappointing that we had to take that off,” he said.
Nocturne is one of a handful of restaurants around the city that will have to stop serving the liver-meat delicacy, which is usually made by force-feeding geese and ducks.
The ban is a victory for animal rights activists who see Denver as a frontier in the fight against cruelty. About 68% of voters in Denver voted for Ordinance 311 last week, approving a measure that described force-feeding as “inhumane” and “painful.”
For some local chefs, it’s more complicated: They are racing to adapt to public opinion — and to prepare for more change. Weadick sees Ordinance 311 as a wake-up call to innovate and develop dishes with similar flavors “without having to have all of the mistreatment of the animal.”
“The first time I ever heard about how gavage works, it was like, ‘That’s pretty effed up,’” he recalled, adding that he was excited to explore concepts like “impossible” foie gras made from mushrooms and other proteins.
Several other restaurants did not answer requests for comment, while a representative of the Colorado Restaurant Association said many were hesitant to speak for fear of backlash. The law takes effect July 1.
Animal activists building momentum
Denver joins a handful of other governments in banning force-fed products. The state of California, along with New York City, Brookline, Mass., and Portland, Ore., have all put limits on foie gras, though the New York ban faces a legal challenge. Washington, D.C., voters also passed a ban this month.
The Denver campaign was proposed by Pro-Animal Colorado, which previously pushed unsuccessful measures to ban slaughterhouses and the sale of fur products in Denver.
Spokesperson Dani Withaar said the organization realized many Denver voters didn’t know that force-feeding birds was still legal.
“It’s frankly ridiculous that this product with a reputation as being one of the most cruel practices in the factory farming system, in our food system in general, is still completely legal to sell,” Withaar said.
Foie gras is created by force-feeding corn mixed with fat to ducks and geese through tubes lodged down their esophaguses two to three times a day for a period of two to three weeks. The process, called “gavage,” causes the birds’ livers to swell up to 10 times their normal size. Then, the birds are slaughtered, and their livers are harvested and prepared by chefs.
“Once they get the disease, then they’re really uncomfortable,” said Dr. Karen Oberthaler, a veterinary oncologist who supported the pro-ban campaign. “They don’t have a diaphragm, so if you swell up their liver, it kind of smooshes their air sac, so they can’t breathe as well. They can’t move around as well.”
Over the past two summers, more than 100 volunteers attended farmers markets and other large events across the city on behalf of Pro-Animal Colorado, including more than 1,000 “voter outreach sessions” in the final months of the campaign.
“A ballot measure, it really was the only way that we could end this cruel practice here in our community because this isn’t a top priority issue for our elected officials, so it was really up to us to end this here,” Withaar said.
Withaar expects more cities and states to follow.
“I really believe that Ordinance 311 may actually end the force-feeding of birds in the U.S. over time, in combination with other laws passed this year in Portland, Oregon, Washington, D.C., New York City, Pittsburgh last year,” Withaar said. “The momentum’s really picking up.”
The impact in Denver
Starting in the summer, businesses selling foie gras could face fines of $1,000 to $5,000. The city’s health department will enforce the law, though city officials don’t expect they’ll need to hire more inspectors or spend any other money on the measure.
Advocates have estimated about 15 restaurants have foie gras on the menu. Several French restaurants, including Chez Maggy and Le Bilboquet, have listed foie gras items recently.
The law also bans the act of force-feeding a bird, but that provision will have relatively little impact, since there do not appear to be any production facilities in the city.
Some specialized producers advertise “free range” foie gras, while researchers are developing methods to turn a duck’s liver into a foie-gras-like product without forced fattening. Other producers say they’ve adopted more “humane” force-feeding strategies. It’s unclear whether any local restaurants are using such products or whether they would be exempted.
For the Colorado Restaurant Association, the ballot measure represents another restriction and an unnecessary encroachment on businesses and customers.
“It’s unfortunate that Denver voters decided to side with special interests, allowing them to dictate what can and can’t be on a restaurant’s menu,” said Nick Hoover, director of government affairs. “We would have preferred that choice prevail in this conversation. Unfortunately, it didn’t.”
He emphasized the importance of choice in Denver’s food scene.
“No one was forcing anyone to order foie gras,” he said. “And I’ll be honest, if someone didn’t want to eat foie gras, they didn’t have to. They could choose not to order it, and if enough people chose not to order it, I promise you, chefs and restaurants would have chosen not to sell it anymore.”
Besides its texture, chefs also value foie gras because fat adds flavor, though its expense means it’s a relatively rare item.
Hoover agrees with the ban’s supporters on one thing: The measure could set a precedent for future forced menu changes, he said.
“I think because of how simple Colorado’s and Denver’s ballot initiative process is that this precedent being set opens up Denver to be ripe for future conversations about what is and isn’t appropriate to be put on a restaurant’s menu, taking away, one, a customer’s choice on what they want to consume, but also chefs’ and restaurants’ choice and creativity in what they want to provide,” he said.
What do you think of the foie gras ban?