Following months of controversy over a football recruiting scandal at Hayfield Secondary School, Fairfax County Public Schools suspended Edison High School boys’ basketball head coach Tre’ Ford for alleged recruitment violations as a Virginia state delegate introduced legislation in Richmond to prevent unethical practices in athletic recruitment.
In an email obtained by the Fairfax County Times, Edison High School Principal Mandy Burke sent a message to parents at 5:16 p.m. on Tuesday, announcing the suspension of the boys’ basketball coach “for the remainder of the school year” for alleged recruitment violations. She said the assistant varsity boys’ basketball coach is now the new head coach.
With the subject line, “Message Regarding Edison Boys Basketball,” Burke wrote, “This decision was made after learning that during a Virginia High School League (VHSL)-sanctioned 2024 summer tournament, several athletes played on the Edison High School boys basketball team who were not enrolled at the school.”
The disciplinary action at Edison, located in Alexandria, has raised questions among area coaches about the consistency of the school district’s oversight, given that FCPS Superintendent Michelle Reid has taken no action against Hayfield Principal Darin Thompson and Hayfield football Coach Darryl Overton despite their program facing months of allegations for serious recruitment misconduct. Moreover, in December, Overton went on a media tour of area podcast shows, speaking openly about the controversy in which he has been embroiled, while FCPS officials have reprimanded coaching staff at other schools for talking to the media. Critics say this discrepancy undermines the district’s credibility in addressing recruitment violations.
Meanwhile, earlier Tuesday, in Richmond, state Delegate Dan Helmer (D, 10th District), a former Division 1 college athlete at the West Point military academy, introduced HB1656, barring school officials from receiving “money or other things of value” to recruit student-athletes and banning the exploitation of the federal McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act to fraudulently claim student-athletes are homeless and automatically register them at a school.
"I am deeply concerned that the amount of cash that is sloshing around college sports is going to move downstream into our public schools, and believe we need to proactively confront that possibility,” Helmer said in an interview with the Fairfax County Times.
"We need to make it harder for adults to make bad decisions,” he added. “If we don't, they will."
In a 5-3 vote, with Delegate Sam Rasoul (D-Roanoke) not voting, the K-12 Subcommittee voted to “report” the bill to the wider Education Committee.
Ironically, just hours after parents got the Edison High School principal’s email, the Edison basketball team walked onto the court to battle Hayfield’s basketball team, with two athletes on the roster who had transferred to the school under a cloud of controversy to play football.
Amid word in the sports community that he is leaving the school and recruiting athletes to go with him, Hayfield football coach Darryl Overton told the Fairfax County Times, “Everything is good. I’m staying at Hayfield.”
Edison High basketball scandal
According to sources, the “several athletes” who played for the Edison team were basketball players allegedly plucked from the roster of a basketball team – “Team Durant” – that competes in a league run by the Amateur Athletic Union, or AAU. According to public records, at least one of the players is now enrolled at Edison and listed on the roster.
Burke, the Edison principal, said she “immediately” launched an investigation upon learning about the alleged violations, working with Tom Horn, director of student activities and athletics at Fairfax County Public Schools.
“While we have completed our review of the summer 2024 tournament, there are allegations regarding player residency and recruiting that we continue to review,” Burke wrote.
Burke said the FCPS Office of Student Activities and Athletics created a “corrective action plan to prevent future issues to enhance oversight of off-season activities. This includes training Edison’s basketball staff and student activities office.”
Critics argue that youth sports have become increasingly corrupted nationally by a system where for-profit youth training coaches select top players who pay for off-season training and steer these athletes into public schools where they coach, allowing them to coach the players year-round and create an unfair advantage to dominate games.
One coach said that it’s “not uncommon” for area public school teams to have athletes on “their summer roster, their live roster, or their fall roster that have not registered at that school…that say they are transferring, but they never do.”
Wider football recruitment scandal
Last year, the Fairfax County Times published a series of articles, “Friday Night Lies,” chronicling allegations of bullying, improper recruitment practices, and retaliation involving Hayfield’s football program.
The controversy erupted last June amid allegations that the school had engaged in unethical recruitment practices under the leadership of Overton, whom the principal, Thompson, recruited to lead the Hayfield program after taking nearby Freedom High School in Prince William County to two state championships. Alleged practices include falsifying student addresses and paying local residents to use their addresses to establish legal residency.
In August, Reid cleared the school of any wrongdoing. In October, after months of investigation, the Virginia High School League imposed a two-year postseason ban on the Hayfield football team. In mid-November, Hayfield parents took the case to court, represented by an FCPS outside law firm, Blankingship & Keith, and its lawyer, John Cafferky, who claimed that he had been retained separately from his work with the school district. A Fairfax County Circuit Court judge, Manuel A. Capsalis, issued a temporary injunction initially allowing the team to participate in the playoffs.
Then, after months of denials by FCPS officials, including Reid, about any wrongdoing, the Fairfax County Times obtained text messages from then-Hayfield athletic director Monty Fritts planning to transfer numerous star athletes to Hayfield with Overton. Most indicting was a plan to exploit school transfer benefits for students in the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act to register players. Fritts resigned following the revelation of the texts.
Reid and Thompson withdrew the team from the playoffs. Days later, following months of calling for such a move by Fairfax County School Board member Mateo Dunne and supported by school board members Ryan McElveen and Ricardy Anderson, the school board voted 12-0 to authorize an independent investigation into the program by an external law firm that hasn’t done business with FCPS for at least 10 years. For the first time, amid a human resources reprimand by the school board for her mishandling of the case, Reid issued a public apology and said “the buck” stopped with her.
New legislation to ‘root out misconduct’
Helmer said he introduced the new legislation after following the Hayfield football scandal, which “disappointed” him. “I believe that most of our educators, most of our coaches, most of our administrators, and all of our school board want the best for our children,” he said.
"It casts a shadow on the amazing work done by so many other coaches and educators who don’t engage in it," he noted.
"My bill is touching on a couple of pieces that we know are really critical, but this needs to be the beginning,” Helmer said. “We need to put consequences in place for those who engage in things that we collectively should agree are misconduct."
"If we pass this bill,” he added, “it is illegal, you can be fired. You can face significant consequences for doing it."
Helmer said he was disturbed by the allegations of the exploitation of federal benefits for homeless students. “The value of athletics and other extracurricular activities to our children is too great for us to put a law in place and just stop there,” he said. “We have to root out misconduct to the greatest extent possible.
"We need to create the framework that encourages the preservation of high school athletics in a way that all of us as parents and as educators think it ought to be preserved," he concluded.