Loomis got nearly triple the votes of outgoing mayor Andrea Horwath after narrowly losing to her last time
Listen to this article
Hamilton voters delivered big change to city hall in Monday's election, putting Keanin Loomis in the mayor's chair and bringing eight new city councillors to the table.
Loomis, president and CEO of the Canadian Institute of Steel Construction and former head of Hamilton's Chamber of Commerce, took the win with 42 per cent of the vote. Former Ward 8 councillor Rob Cooper placed second, with 32 per cent, outgoing mayor Andrea Horwath landed in third, with 15 per cent, and Scarlett Gillespie placed fourth, with seven per cent.
It was Loomis' second attempt at the job after losing to Horwath by 1,600 votes in 2022.
In the lead-up to election day, Loomis promised to make Hamilton safer, get taxes "under control" and fix Hamilton's roads and infrastructure. He also voted to implement "firm and fair management of public spaces" by moving people from the streets into housing and shelters. He also pledged to build 5,000 affordable housing units in four years.
He told his supporters assembled at downtown concert venue Bridgeworks that he'll be the mayor for all the city, not just those who voted for him.
WATCH | Hamilton's next mayor promises to fight for steelworkers and their families:
"Voters have had enough of the negativity," Loomis said in a speech, thanking his team for running what he called a positive campaign. He also thanked his opponents and his family, including his two children, promising them "at least one meal, someday soon, where nobody talks about politics," adding, "I’m doing this for you and all the young people in the city."
After the speech, he told reporters he was thrilled to be taking the mayor's job five years after first working towards it.
"Last time around was incredible," he said. "I got a chance to connect with tens of thousands of Hamiltonians." This time around, he said, people wanted change.
Loomis also commented on the city's nearly two-hour delay releasing any election results, which city staff told CBC News was related to a difficulty transmitting results between polling stations and city hall.
"All the other communities are reporting results and we, for some reason, are laggards again," he said. "We're going to celebrate. We're not going to worry about that. We will talk about that though tomorrow."
At her election-night party, Gillespie said she would run again, although maybe next time as a councillor.
"People want real representation, and I think I offered that to them," she said. "When they got a taste of it, they will continue to want that real, authentic representation."
Residents driven by cost of living, homelessness
Throughout the campaign, residents told candidates and CBC News that the cost of living was a major priority, alongside homelessness, road infrastructure and transportation.
McMaster University political scientist Peter Graefe noted candidates in this election somehow managed to steer clear of the debates around data centres and the urban boundary, big issues before the campaign that quickly gave way.
Instead, the candidates' focus narrowed toward housing, homelessness and "municipal property taxes competence."
"There has been an increase in the taxes, but some sense that city hall isn't being run in a way to actually make good use" of the money, Graefe told CBC Hamilton on Friday.
Graefe said the campaign seemed to lack engagement, both from voters and candidates, many of whom limited their campaigning to "distributing flyers." He said an absence of polling made it hard for voters to make strategic choices.
Voter turnout Monday was less than 32 per cent, down from 35 per cent in 2022.
Horwath struggled to explain her vision, says expert
Horwath, a former Hamilton city councillor, led the Ontario New Democratic Party from 2009 to 2022. She served as MPP for Hamilton Centre from 2004 to 2022 before being elected as the city's mayor.
While it's more common than not for an incumbent mayor to lose in Hamilton — only Fred Eisenberger has won consecutive mayoral terms since amalgamation — Graefe said Horwath struggled to articulate her vision for the city.
Voters "were tired of the current mayor and felt that there were some imitations to the quality of her stewardship of of the municipal corporation," he added.
However, he said Loomis' lack of experience in municipal politics will mean he'll need time to find his footing.
"I suspect we'll see an attempt to put together a team and a broad vision for where the city should move forward. I think his real challenge is going to be actually connecting that to the places that make decisions in the city bureaucracy," he said.
Past Horwath voters switch allegiances
Christine Huddleston was at Loomis's election-night party after spending the last several weeks volunteering for his campaign. She said in the last election she supported Horwath but came to feel she'd "made a huge mistake."
"I got involved because I felt if you don't, you can't complain," she said, adding that if more people paid attention and got involved, she thinks they'd get more of what they want out of city hall.
Dofasco steel mill worker Craig Waite also changed his vote this time after supporting Horwath in 2022. He went with Cooper, saying he was solely driven by who he thought would keep his property tax bill the lowest.
Waite said he felt the city wastes money on poorly planned infrastructure, and was appalled by how much went to recover the city's technology after it was hacked, something he blamed on poor management by the mayor.
"It was another debacle and waste of money," he said.
Horwath did not attend her campaign's election night event at Henry's on James Street North. When CBC Hamilton went by the venue at 11:30 p.m., it was empty and dark.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Saira Peesker is a reporter and producer with CBC Hamilton, with particular interests in climate, labour and local politics. She has previously worked with the Hamilton Spectator and CTV News, and is a regular contributor to the Globe and Mail, covering business and personal finance.
With files from Aura Carreño Rosas, Justin Chandler, Brittany Spencer and Jeffery Tram