Click here for important updates to our privacy policy.
HISTORY
The MetroWest Daily News
NATICK — The Sawin House will be demolished. And without meaningful delay.
The Massachusetts Audubon Society has informed the Natick Select Board and advocates of preserving the 1696 property that it will not delay its plans to demolish the structure.
“Mass Audubon has never, never been interested in doing anything different with the house,” said Henry Haugland of Natick Heritage Inc., a nonprofit created to try to save and renovate the house. “Every time we presented something, there was always some sort of new objection that cropped up. It is what it is.”
The Sawin House is on Mass Audubon’s Broadmoor Wildlife Sanctuary in South Natick. The nonprofit may tear down the home as early as Feb. 19 after rejecting the Select Board’s request to delay demolition for six months, and give Natick Heritage a chance to come up with a plan to save it.
In a statement, Mass Audubon said it wants to help honor the history of the home and what it represents.
“At the request of the Select Board, we met once again to talk about options for the Sawin House," Mass Audubon said. "While we are moving forward with our demolition plan, Mass Audubon has offered to preserve some of the original components of the house and is talking with Natick Heritage about salvaging those items.
The organization also said it "remains committed to creating a meaningful historic interpretation experience at the site, in partnership with Natick Historical Society and indigenous partners."
"This has been a 15-year process, with many alternatives discussed and Mass Audubon even offering to transfer ownership to the Town at one point, but unfortunately a final agreement was never reached," Mass Audubon officials stated. "With the condition of the building continuing to degrade and posing a significant safety risk, we feel this is the best course of action.”
The Sawin House was built in 1696 by Thomas Sawin after reaching an agreement with Sarah Awassamug, head of the Natick Praying Indians. Sawin was allowed to build the home and mills in exchange for providing milled products to the Praying Indians.
Deal to build Sawin house is 'part of our heritage'
Haugland said the home itself is important, but what it represents is even more. He said Sawin and Awassamug put aside mutual distrust after King Philip’s War (1675-76) to develop a mutually beneficial partnership that triggered economic and industrial development in MetroWest.
“The fact that they could work together after what had happened just 10, 15, years earlier, is remarkable,” Haugland said. “They established industry in MetroWest. It’s a key part of our heritage.”
During Wednesday’s Select Board meeting, Chairwoman Kathryn Coughlin said Mass Audubon would be willing to set aside some historical pieces so they can be preserved and used in a future memorial.
“What they did offer during the demolition process is to salvage the staircase, which is original, and one or more of the beams, which are original, and there’s a stone in the basement where Sawin’s name is carved and a date,” she said.
She said the items would fit in a storage Pod, which could be kept on town property until Natick Heritage, if interested, comes up with a memorial plan to put the items in one of the town’s parks.
In addition, Coughlin said Mass Audubon plans to work with the Natick Historical Society and “indigenous partners" to come up with a way to honor the history the house represented at the sanctuary, she said.
Board member Bruce Evans said Mass Audubon expressed concern over Natick Heritage's ability to raise the necessary funds and be long-term partners.
“The bottom line is historic preservation is feasible, house restoration is not,” he said. “Mass Audubon wants to help preserve history, but it cannot conflict with its core mission.”
Select Board member Linda Wollschlager expressed sadness that the house would not be saved.
“I understand they have a different mission, but this is the oldest house in Natick, and I was hoping there could be different resolution to this,” she said.
Select Board member says historical items can be made more accessible
Coughlin said one benefit is that the items salvaged can be displayed in a more accessible location.
“This might be — it’s not the best solution, by far — but it may be a solution that gives better access to this history,” she said.
Coughlin said she and Evans would meet with Natick Heritage to discuss the potential salvage of items and if the group is interested in raising money to set up a permanent memorial.
The original goal, Haugland said Thursday, was to renovate the home and have it stand as a memorial for the importance of the partnership between Sawin and the Natick Praying Indians. He said he's worried that any other memorial could fall flat and be more difficult to raise money for.
“The first thing is the memorial has to match the significance of what you're creating it for,” he said. “The second thing, it must be created so it's perpetual, so it's under the control of someone. I’m not sure what we’re going to do.”
George Sawin, a seventh-generation grandson of Thomas Sawin and his wife Deborah, expressed disappointment in Mass Audubon’s decision, calling it “completely insensitive.”
He said Natick Heritage had a plan and people in place who could raise the money, but that it didn’t matter to Mass Audubon.
“For them to respond out of hand like they did, it feels adolescent, it feels like an oblivious and obtuse response,” said Sawin, who lives in Westwood. “They have opportunities to be real heroes to the community in a way that wouldn’t cost them a dime and wouldn’t cause any disruption, but they’re sitting back saying no with no real reason.”
Norman Miller can be reached at 508-626-3823 or [email protected]. For up-to-date public safety news, follow him on X @Norman_MillerMW or on Facebook at facebook.com/NormanMillerCrime.