The board president joined the district's secrecy on who signed off on personal spending.
Patch Staff
|Updated Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 7:20 am CT
ELMHURST, IL – The head of the Elmhurst School District 205 board won't say whether the district should reveal who, if anyone, approved questionable credit card spending.
"Being a current board member, I cannot comment on personnel matters," board President Athena Arvanitis said in response to a Patch candidate questionnaire last month.
At least a couple of her election rivals say the information on the approvals should be released.
In December, Patch reported that Todd Schmidt, the district's former facilities director, spent $46,000 on his public credit card for personal purposes, including on booze, cigars, restaurant meals and sorority payments, among other things.
Schmidt, arrested in November on charges of stealing from his mother, reimbursed the district every month with checks, essentially getting unofficial short-term loans.
Find out what's happening in Elmhurstfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Public records don't indicate who approved the spending, and the district has declined to say.
In January, the board struck a severance agreement with Schmidt's supervisor, Chris Whelton, assistant superintendent of finance, who agreed to resign at the end of February.
The district has hired an auditing firm to investigate its finances, an inquiry that is expected to last a few months.
Besides Arvanitis, four other candidates – John Bishof, Tom Chavez, Brian Bresnahan and Nicole "Nikki" Slowinski – are running for the school board in the April 1 election. Arvanitis is the lone incumbent. Three of the seven board seats are up.
In last month's questionnaire, Patch noted the district's decision to stay quiet about who approved Schmidt's credit card arrangement. The candidates were asked whether the district should reveal the information.
Two candidates, John Bishof and Tom Chavez, called for openness in this situation.
"I believe in transparency, so I think they should reveal this information," Bishof said. "However, it would seem that Chris Whelton took responsibility by offering his resignation."
Chavez, a longtime board critic, said the secrecy was another example of the district's "stonewalling" of taxpayers.
"Superintendent Keisha Campbell needs to come clean on the Schmidt/Whelton regime and provide full and complete transparency to the taxpayers of Elmhurst," he said. "Every contract that Whelton/Schmidt touched needs heavy scrutiny. Anything less is completely unacceptable and should raise eyebrows and suspicion that D205 has something to hide from taxpayers."
Bresnahan said transparency and accountability were essential in maintaining the public's trust in the district. Without being a part of the district's discussions, he said it was difficult to speak on what officials have found.
He said the discussion highlights a need for a reevaluation of the district's oversight, making sure proper safeguards are in place.
"I expect that the district has identified where those safeguards went wrong and are immediately strengthening them to ensure our tax dollars are preserved," Bresnahan said.
Slowsinski, though, appeared to take Arvanitis' position.
"I think the district should handle this in the same way they would handle all personnel investigations," she said. "Many times, particularly during an investigation, organizations are not able to share information and doing so can create undue risks."