The former board president says he thinks Superintendent Michael Lach should be replaced.
Patch Staff
|Updated Tue, Mar 4, 2025 at 5:26 pm CT
HINSDALE, IL – The former president of the Hinsdale High School District 86 board is not a fan of the district's new superintendent.
Erik Held, who left the board in May 2023, targeted Superintendent Michael Lach's recent interview with the Hinsdalean weekly newspaper. Lach appeared to dismiss the five-year effort toward equal course opportunities between Central and South – often referred to as "alignment."
The larger Central, with a wealthier student body, has long had a greater course selection.
Lach, who started last July, has not returned Patch's messages for comment. The current board president, Catherine Greenspon, did not return a message Monday.
In a recent Facebook post, Held, who served four years, said Lach should be replaced.
Find out what's happening in Hinsdale-Clarendon Hillsfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
"So many fought so hard in 2018/19 during the referendum to promote 'One District, Two Schools' that to promote curricular separation is a slap in the face to their hard work," Held said.
Held accused Greenspon and the board in 2023 of "decapitating district leadership and morale" and waging a "Make Central Great Again" shadow campaign. That campaign, he said, was to separate Central from South under the guise of "helping" South be its best self.
"'Opportunities Alignment' starts with Curricular Alignment and a unified Program of Studies," said Held, who did not run for a second term. "We then work to fix what is made difficult by staffing, cost and head count disparities when possible."
In an email to Patch this week, Held said he viewed Lach skeptically because he encouraged his last school system, Highland Park-based High School District 113, to eliminate his position. He served in the position known in many districts as the assistant superintendent for academics.
Lach's boss at the time, Superintendent Bruce Law, who held the same job previously in District 86, backed doing away with the position, according to a story last year in The Record North Shore. (The school board kept it.)
Law told The Record that the principals at the district's two schools – Highland Park and Deerfield – are "really well-positioned to be instructional leaders in their buildings."
"I have become convinced that in District 113 ... the schools really have such individual characters and histories and cultures that they really work fairly independently of each other," Law told The Record. “It occurred to me that (assistant superintendent for academics) needed to be pushed down to the buildings, especially to the principals. That’s where the work really gets done.”
Held disagreed with such an idea.
"District curriculum coordination is vital in a multi-school system. Creating artificial divisions based on what zip code the buildings are in doesn't help the culture of the District, and it certainly doesn't help the students," Held said in the email. "I don't believe the principals' offices should be driving curriculum in D86; it unfairly burdens them with someone else's job. It's the responsibility of a combination of faculty and administration to create a unified program for the whole District, and all the big and little things that come afterwards."
He continued, "I'm not an educator or administrator. I view the work we did, and its unifying nature, as a net positive, especially with a small but visible group of residents believing D86 should be split."
Held is not the first former board president to speak out against a superintendent.
In April 2021, former President Nancy Pollak, who resigned suddenly 10 months before, criticized then-Superintendent Tammy Prentiss on Facebook.
"Perhaps now the entire D86 community will realize the problem is the Superintendent and her failure to understand who she works for and how to balance those needs," Pollak said in her message.
Like Lach, Prentiss did not comment.