Western Cape MEC Anton Bredell is threatening legal action over Theewaterskloof Municipality’s decision to retain Tracy Mbalo-Tshungwana as acting director.
Image: Phando Jikelo/African News Agency (ANA Archives)
The Western Cape Government is preparing to take Theewaterskloof Municipality to court over its decision to retain an acting director whose qualifications and appointment have been questioned by Local Government MEC Anton Bredell.
In a letter dated October 29, Bredell told the municipal Speaker that the council had voted two days earlier to keep Tracy Mbalo-Tshungwana as Acting Director of Community Services, despite his department’s assessment that her CV, qualifications and appointment did not meet the statutory minimum requirements for the position.
Bredell said the department had been instructed to institute legal proceedings to have the appointment declared unlawful. It will also seek any further relief recommended by its legal team, including a possible costs order against councillors who supported her continued appointment.
“In light of Council’s resolution, the Department of Local Government has been instructed to institute legal proceedings declaring that her appointment is unlawful,” Bredell wrote.
The proposed legal challenge follows earlier correspondence from Bredell dated October 8, in which he raised concerns about the appointment and the minimum qualification requirements.
MEC says department will challenge council decision
Bredell also indicated that the department would seek “any other relief” advised by its legal representatives, as well as a cost order against councillors who supported Mbalo-Tshungwana’s continued acting appointment.
His spokesperson, Wouter Kriel, said the department could not comment further because of the prospect of legal proceedings.
“We cannot comment on this matter at this point in time as it may influence legal proceedings,” Kriel said.
He did not dispute the authenticity of the October 29 letter.
The dispute follows an earlier legal confrontation between Bredell and the municipality over a senior appointment. In 2024, a court challenge over the appointment of Theewaterskloof municipal manager Wilfred Solomons-Johannes ended in a settlement that declared his appointment unlawful and set it aside.
Municipality declines to comment on council decision
Theewaterskloof Municipality spokesperson Tarren-Lee Habelgaarn confirmed that the matter had been discussed at a special in-committee council meeting.
“In-committee meetings are confidential, and the administration, therefore, cannot comment on decisions taken by Council during these proceedings,” she said.
Habelgaarn referred further enquiries to the Speaker’s office.
Acting director’s qualifications questioned
Mbalo-Tshungwana has been Town Manager of Grabouw since 2022.
Previous media reports about her appointment as Town Manager described her as having worked in revenue management at the City of Cape Town and as an operations manager in the Department of Transport and Public Works.
They also reported that she had been a member of the provincial legislature’s agriculture and environmental affairs committee and had served in the Premier’s department.
Her LinkedIn profile lists her as an MBA candidate at Henley Business School Africa, with studies beginning in April 2026. It also lists postgraduate business administration studies at Henley.
In a Facebook post about her graduation in July 2024, she referred to a postgraduate qualification in business administration at NQF Level 8.
The department’s assessment of her qualifications and appointment is disputed by the council’s decision to retain her. The proposed court proceedings are expected to seek a determination on the legality of the appointment.
Councillors reportedly back continued appointment
A sitting Theewaterskloof councillor told IOL Media that Mbalo-Tshungwana remained in the acting director position despite Bredell’s legal threat.
The councillor said the ANC, EFF and PA had voted in favour of retaining her.
The councillor also said the three parties had supported the removal of mayor Lincoln de Bruyn last month.
De Bruyn was subsequently reinstated after the DA in Theewaterskloof approached the courts to have his removal declared unconstitutional.
The municipality has experienced repeated political upheaval, including the latest removal of De Bruyn amid coalition tensions.