North Pole Creamery Expands with New Indoor Location in Downtown Milford
MILFORD, DE — A beloved downtown ice cream shop is expanding, bringing year-round sweet treats and indoor seating to the heart of Milford. Dave Pickrell, owner of North Pole Creamery, is preparing to open a new storefront at 10 S Walnut St.
Pickrell and his wife moved to Milford 12 years ago and have been actively involved in revitalizing the historic downtown district. His wife owns Gallery 37, a fine arts gallery that has been a staple in the community for over a decade. Living above the gallery for years, the couple witnessed firsthand the changes and growth in the area, which ultimately led to Pickrell’s decision to open North Pole Creamery in 2020.
The original North Pole Creamery operates out of a small red building, known locally as the Santa House, which had previously sat dormant for most of the year. Pickrell saw an opportunity to turn it into a community hub, offering all-natural, hand-dipped ice cream in a scenic outdoor setting. However, the shop’s lack of indoor seating and its seasonal operation from May to October prompted Pickrell to take the next step.
“We decided to open an indoor location,” Pickrell said. “We own the commercial buildings across the street where the gallery and our apartment were, and we’re turning one of them into a full-scale ice cream shop with seating for over 17 people.”
The new location will allow North Pole Creamery to expand its menu beyond hand-dipped ice cream. Customers can expect classic malt shop treats such as milkshakes, banana splits, sundaes, and a variety of toppings. Pickrell envisions a nostalgic ice cream parlor atmosphere that will complement the existing outdoor Riverwalk location.
“The Santa House will still be open with a limited menu and outdoor seating,” he explained. “People can grab their ice cream and still enjoy the quiet, relaxing space by the river.”
North Pole Creamery at the Santa House
The expansion has been in the works for some time, with Pickrell navigating the necessary city permits and final inspections. He anticipates opening the new storefront by the end of April, pending approvals and final construction work.
Beyond serving ice cream, Pickrell is committed to supporting the local community. He has consistently employed local high school students from Milford and Lake Forest, and he plans to continue prioritizing young employees for the new location.
“I’ve been really fortunate with the staff I’ve had,” he said. “I’m looking to hire more local high school kids to be part of the team as we expand.”
Pickrell also partners with nonprofit organizations, particularly dog rescues, hosting ice cream socials to raise awareness and help dogs find homes. His homemade dog-friendly ice cream has been a hit in the community, offering a healthy treat for pets and their owners alike.
With the new North Pole Creamery location set to open soon, Pickrell hopes to further strengthen the shop’s role as a gathering place for the Milford community. “We’re excited to grow and bring people together over good, old-fashioned ice cream.”
For updates on the grand opening and job opportunities, follow North Pole Creamery on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/NPCreamery or visit in person at the Santa House location in downtown Milford. 1 South Walnut Street, Milford, DE, United States.
READ: https://milfordlive.com/sussex-conservation-district-2025-csa-winners/