Records show 20 of 80 emails between county liaison and school facilities director received no response
RICHMOND, Va. (WWBT) - Emails obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request show a Henrico County employee hired to help resolve HVAC problems in Henrico County Public Schools went unanswered by the school division’s facilities director on at least 20 occasions since June.
The 80 emails span communications between Eric Sears, who works with Henrico County General Services, and Susan Moore, facilities director for Henrico County Public Schools, since Sears started his role in June.
The On Your Side Investigators reviewed the records.
Henrico County created Sears’ position in General Services late last school year to serve as a liaison between the county and the school division on HVAC repairs, and to coordinate with vendors and contracted technicians.
According to the county, 70 schools in the division have experienced some type of air conditioning issue since students returned to class.
On July 1, Sears emailed Moore with the subject line “Pre school year HVAC checks,” asking, “Does Henrico maintenance staff or contractors perform any operational or performance checks to equipment prior to August?”
He received no reply.
Sears waited 28 days before sending a follow-up email on July 29.
Moore replied six hours later that day, forwarding the question to Robert Isbell, HCPS mechanical trades supervisor. Isbell responded: “Maintenance staff perform performance checks weekly. And perform quarterly filter changes and belts checks as well. Weekly checks in the summer depend on occupied status of the zones.”
Records also show it took weeks for Sears to gain full access to school buildings to inspect HVAC systems himself.
On July 20, HCPS Chief of Staff Michelle Boyd emailed Moore to help arrange badge access for Sears.
Other emails from Sears that went unanswered, this includes an Aug. 4 message to Moore and Isbell that included a photo of a boiler and maintenance questions; an Aug. 5 email asking about HVAC plans for the new Fairfield Elementary School; an Aug. 11 email to Moore and Isbell seeking help with a broken chiller at Greenwood Elementary School; an Aug. 14 email asking to schedule a review of startup issues for the week of Sept. 7; and emails sent Aug. 18, 21 and 26 regarding HVAC issues at Trevvett Elementary School and Highland Springs High School.
An Aug. 13 email chain shows the school division scrambling to secure rental air conditioning units days before students returned to class.
Tom Wilkins, assistant director of facilities for HCPS operations, contacted a representative from Spot Coolers, a division of Carrier Corporation, to ask about accessing more units.
The company replied that it is a member of several purchasing cooperatives that make it easier for school districts to purchase or rent equipment.
Wilkins forwarded that information to Kennedy Venaglia, HCPS finance division director of purchasing and delivery services, writing: “We are in desperate need of additional spot coolers. I am trying so put together an RQ this morning.”
Venaglia contacted Justin Herbaugh in Henrico County’s purchasing division about the request.
Herbaugh then escalated the matter to Henrico Purchasing Director Oscar Knott, writing: “Is this ‘spot cooler purchase’ something you were aware of coming in hot? I’m assuming it will be a significant dollar commitment and thought you would want to be brought into the loop ASAP.”
Knott replied: “1st I’m hearing of spot coolers.”
Knott then looped in Sears, writing: “The terms and conditions on the quote is a problem. Other than that, I don’t understand why they continue to need to purchase spot coolers. They should have 100s in inventory right now based on the last few years of buying these things for temporary use. By now the permanent units that they were bought to supplement should have been repaired/replaced and we shouldn’t need to continue to buy more units.”
Knott asked Sears to look into the matter, saying, “something just seems off.”
Venaglia responded that facilities staff reported roughly 280 spot coolers installed in schools awaiting various repairs, with only 15 spare units in the warehouse, and said several schools could require a significant number of additional units before Aug. 24.
Sears forwarded the email chain to Moore on Aug. 14 and did not receive a reply.
As of Sept. 1, Henrico County Public Schools spokesperson Eileen Cox said the division has, “rented approximately 130 portable air conditioning units for temporary use as mechanical needs are being addressed.”
Rental fees have topped $165,000 and are continuing to climb, according to a county source.
The 12 On Your Side Investigators have several additional FOIA requests pending with Henrico County Public Schools.
The division has requested thousands of dollars to fulfill the requests.