NEW CARLISLE – Casey McKim had about as successful of a five-year run you can have as New Prairie head football coach.
Four straight sectional titles the last four seasons after a 5-5 campaign in 2020. He added a regional title in 2021, plus a semistate crown in 2022 to reach the IHSAA Class 4A state championship game. An overall record of 48-17 the last five years made the Cougars one of the premier programs in the South Bend area.
That’s why leaving is difficult for him.
McKim informed his team Tuesday morning that he’d be taking the head coaching job at Lowell High School, pending school board approval. Ironically, McKim had a 4-0 record against the Red Devils during his time leading New Prairie, including that regional championship win in 2021.
“I just felt like it was a move I needed to make to keep growing, professionally and personally,” McKim said to the Tribune by phone Tuesday morning. “Obviously, I was at a tremendous place that was extremely hard to leave, especially the kids and outstanding coaching staff that’s here.
“There are other things that are a part of the mix, when you look at program building. The biggest thing, in my mind, is that I was aligned and had some similar ideas and focus into what I’m trying to do, professionally. I just felt it was a really good alignment of those things.”
McKim noted things moved quickly with Lowell.
“I didn’t start the process thinking I was going to leave, but as the process continued, it was extremely impressive,” McKim said. “So, I had to make a really, really difficult decision.”
McKim replaces Keith Kilmer, who had a decorated 15-year run that included reaching the Class 4A state title game in 2017. Kilmer went 115-60 overall with six sectional, two regional and one semistate titles. He had been with the football program since 1995, serving a multitude of roles before head coach.
“There’s a lot of strong, passionate football people out here,” said McKim of Lowell. “Early in the process, I brought up the fact that, in 4A football the last 25 years, they’re the most successful program in the northern half of the state. You have that history and background.”
Lowell is coming off a 4-6 season, but McKim is excited about what the future holds in northwest Indiana.
“They had a major facilities upgrade,” McKim noted. “They check all the boxes that a coach could want from every single aspect that you look at a program.”
Meanwhile, New Prairie will look for a new head coach after going 9-4 with a sectional title last year. It was a senior-heavy group for the Cougars, as junior quarterback Reed Robinson is the only statistical leader returning. The top five tacklers, top three interceptors and all 14 sacks recorded on defense, plus the top two rushers (outside Robinson) and top eight pass catchers on offense will have to be replaced.
“It’s a wave of emotions and memories — there’s a lot,” said McKim of his time at New Prairie. “My second year, when we won at the regional — oddly enough, at Lowell – I thought was a huge stepping stone for our program. … sometimes, as coaches, you remember the negatives or remember the games you should’ve won. Along with that is how you responded to that, and the thing that’s going to stick out in my mind is we always found a way to respond to adversity.”
Follow Austin Hough on X (formerly Twitter) @AustinRHough and on Facebook at "Austin Hough - South Bend Tribune." Hough can be emailed at [email protected].