A bill that would replace the South Carolina High League was put on hold Wednesday, but not before legislators levied heavy criticism toward the entity that manages high school sports in the state.
The S.C. House Education and Public Works’ full committee voted 14-3 to adjourn discussion of House Bill 4163, which would rebrand the SCHSL as the state-run S.C. Athletic Association. Discussion on the bill will resume in January, but the committee and the SCHSL plan to talk extensively once lawmakers are out of session.
While the bill did not advance, several legislators used Wednesday’s meeting to take shots at the league. One even asked for the resignation of SCHSL commissioner Jerome Singleton.
Singleton, who was in attendance at Wednesday’s meeting, was called on by the committee to speak.
“We have had conversations with our athletic directors and coaches, and maybe we don’t want the High School League to go away, but the common denominator I have heard over and over was ‘Jerome, Jerome, Jerome. Jerome,’ ” said state Rep. Stephen Frank, R-Greenville. “Would you, sir, at this point moving forward as we go in this off-session to work with your organization, consider stepping down and let the interim director come in and help shepherd this process forward?”
Singleton had a simple response, “No, sir.”
The State reached out to Singleton after the meeting to get his perspective and ask whether he was caught off guard by getting asked to leave the SCHSL. He said he wasn’t really surprised by Grant’s comments and reaffirmed that he has no plans of stepping down as commissioner.
Singleton also understands why he gets the brunt of people’s criticism associated with the SCHSL.
“I’m the constant. Everyone else is transient,” Singleton said. “Every four years, we got a brand new committee. I’m one of the ones you can recognize at the league and put a name with it. Every year we change (executive committee) presidents. In the past, it was every two years. But every four years we change executive committee members. So I’m the constant name that could be reached. I believe I get a lot of credit for things I don’t deserve and I believe I get a lot of criticism. Both of which I don’t have control over.”
The S.C. High School League has been in place since 1913. It is a public entity but not an agency within state government. The proposed S.C. Athletic Association would fall underneath the Department of Education.
A lot of the criticism toward the High School League has centered around what lawmakers say is an outdated structure for dealing with modern-day issues facing athletics such as competitive balance, athlete eligibility and player transfers. How the league has enforced sanctions against member schools for rules violations has also been called inconsistent and sometimes unfair.
In the April 22 meeting of the S.C. House’s Education and Public Works K-12 Subcommittee, Singleton was called upon to speak and was grilled by some committee members, including Rep. James Teeple, R-Charleston.
Teeple again had strong words for Singleton and the SCHSL during Wednesday’s meeting. He called the SCHSL “a dumpster fire that has been burning for a long time.” He wasn’t in favor of adjourning the bill and wanted to see something passed.
“My fear is they will appease, appease until the heat is off and go back to status quo in putting kids second and programs first,” Teeple said. “I have been in sports my entire life. … I’m not anti-sport. We want to make it better.”
If the committee had voted in favor of the bill, it would have moved on to the full S.C. House of Representatives. It would need to pass the House and S.C. Senate and then be signed by Gov. Henry McMaster to become a law and goes into effect. The target date for the bill going into effect was before the 2026-27 school year.
“It is a disingenuous attempt to get the heat off. I don’t trust them. I think we have a massive leadership problem in this organization,” Teeple said. “I don’t think they deserve to be in this leadership position. Until … you cut the head off the snake, I’ve got serious reservations.”
Singleton, a Newberry College graduate, has been the SCHSL’s commissioner since 2007, when he replaced Ronnie Matthews. Before taking that position, he was an SCHSL executive director for 2005-07 and assistant/associate executive director for 10 years.
“They have had their chance,” Teeple said. “Not just strike three but six, seven and eight. I think it is time to gut this organization and rebuild it in a fair and transparent process.”
Rep. Shannon Erickson, R-Beaufort, who chairs the House Education and Public Works Committee, also has been an outspoken critic of the S.C. High School League. But she said Wednesday that she is willing to work with the league toward a solution.
Erickson said she’s been pleased with the league’s response and willingness to cooperate, which she said hasn’t always been the case. She said she has already had one meeting with the league’s executive committee.
“It pains me to take the chance we are kicking the can down the road without something concrete being done today,” Erickson said. “I am putting it on record that this is not a personal thing. It has been shared that I want to ruin sports. Nothing could be further from the truth. I just wanted to see our students have good fair play and our students have a system that works for most of them better than it has been.”
Singleton said he was appreciative of Erickson and the committee for delaying the decision so there could be more time for dialogue. He said no date has been set for the first meeting but that it will involve all interested members from the state lawmakers as well as the SCHSL executive committee.
“I appreciate the work of Representative Erickson for calling for a pause until we had a chance for meaningful dialogue and collaboration,” Singleton said. “And hopefully we can address some of the challenges that they have been having.”
This story was originally published April 30, 2025 at 12:48 PM.
The State
(803) 771-8419
Lou Bezjak is the High School Sports Prep Coordinator for The (Columbia) State and (Hilton Head) Island Packet. He previously worked at the Florence Morning News and had covered high school sports in South Carolina since 2002. Lou is a two-time South Carolina Sports Writer of the Year by the National Sports Media Association. Support my work with a digital subscription