Anthony Iachello doesn’t care that Jillian Heyser is only a freshman.
With the swings she’s put together against some of the state’s top pitchers, he knew she earned her place near the top of Colts Neck’s lineup.
And on Saturday afternoon against the No. 9 team in the state — Mount St. Dominic in the Public/Private Challenge— she officially showed why.
The two-hole hitter for Colts Neck, she launched the biggest hit of her career — a game-winning three-run homer to dead center against Mount pitcher Abby Cianfrocca to put Colts Neck up 6-5 in the top of the sixth.
“She doesn’t let the moment get too big for her, and that’s really impressive as a freshman,” Colts Neck pitcher Angela Sasso said. “We’ve been so proud of her, whether it’s in the outfield or cheering us on in the dugout. She’s made great adjustments hitting and that ball was so clutch.”
Sasso got hit around at times, including early on when Mount’s All-State first baseman Jillian Cianfrocca opened the game with a solo blast to tie the game at 1-1.
But Sasso wasn’t worried and didn’t let that hit — or any of the others she gave up faze her.
Mount right fielder Carlee Paez also hit Sasso well, going 3-for-3 with three RBI singles. Even with all that traffic, though, Sasso got big outs when it counted.
She struck out 15 in the game and got out of several big jams.
The slugfest was far different from last year’s meeting between the two sides when Mount won 1-0 in 10 innings as Sasso struck out 16 and Mount’s then-frosh Ava Kelshaw struck out 16 and tossed a no-hitter.
But after pitching the last two games for Mount and despite being listed as the starter pregame, Mount coach Rob Stern started Natalia Marecki in the circle instead.
Still, regardless of who Colts Neck saw, the Cougars were prepared. They’re in a division with three of the state’s top teams and top pitchers in St. John Vianney’s Madison McDougall, Middletown North’s Madilynn Boyce and Red Bank Catholic’s Lily Hagan.
And though Colts Neck dropped its games against those three, the Cougars were competitive and it prepares them for anything.
“Our division is probably one of the best in the state, but those results haven’t brought our confidence down but it’s actually brought it up,” Sasso said. “Because we know if we’re fouling the ball of them or in the game with them, we can be in the game with anyone.”
Knolls plays its style, continues winning streak
Known all over the state for their aggressiveness on the bases, both stealing and taking extra bases and creating havoc for the opposing team, Morris Knolls was in top form on Saturday.
The Golden Eagles trailed 2-0 early but Morris Knolls showed early what it was willing to do when Julia Fox stole third with two outs in the top of the first.
From there, coach Keith Heinemann gave his team a perpetual green light and the Golden Eagles took advantage, scoring five in the bottom of the third thanks to a two-RBI double by Fox, two stolen bases in the inning and runners advancing from first to second on several throws.
They put up two in the bottom of the fourth and then after getting six straight base runners to begin the bottom of the fifth, All-State shortstop Taylor Heinemann walked things off with an RBI single to deep center and end it 12-2.
And after a 1-3 start to the year, Knolls has won three in a row.
“We just had to figure some things out on our end those first couple of games,” Heinemann said. “I think any time you can apply pressure to people, it’s good. Whether you’re hitting doubles or running the bases, you make them play.”
Watchung Hills turns it on late, starts rounding into form
Even after an eight run win over St. Mary (Ruth.), Watchung Hills coach Brian Figueiredo gave his team an impassioned plea.
The Warriors led 1-0 for much of the game and then 2-0 before an eight run sixth inning helped propel them to a 10-2 lead.
All-State pitcher Riley Bobrowski was lights out to start the game for the state’s No. 4 team, retiring the first seven St. Mary’s batters in a row and tossing a no-hitter through the first three innings, but Figueiredo still wanted more.
The Warriors beat Summit, 1-0 in eight innings, beat Union County champs Dayton 1-0 as well and beat reigning Somerset County champs Immaculata in eight innings and were close to another close result against a non-conference opponent.
“I just thought we could have had a little better mindset today,” Figueiredo said. “Some of these non-conference games, teams are up against us and want to play and beat us and we’ve got to make sure we’re answering the call.”
The Warriors managed only six hits, but drew 13 walks as Bobrowski notched two hits and drove in two runs en route to tossing four innings, K’ing nine and walking just one.
All-State utility player Mia Simon came in and pitched the last two innings, giving up two hits, two walks and two earned runs while striking out five and the Warriors deployed two courtesy/pinch runners and two pinch hitters as well, showing off their depth in the process.
“We have a varsity roster this year where we have a lot of comparable parts with no real drop off in spots,” Figueiredo said.
And while Watchung Hills is focused on playing its best softball in late May and early June, Figueiredo did acknowledge that if the Warriors
“I hate to see it, but you have to learn a tough lesson sometimes,” he said. “We’ve been in a lot of close games and we’ve managed to pull them out. But when you keep the other team in the game, you set yourself up for the worst outcome.”
Dunn makes sure Mo. Cath’s upset a done deal
Perhaps no one delivered a bigger hit on Saturday than Morris Catholic’s sophomore third baseman Rachel Dunn.
The Crusaders — ranked No. 13 in the state — seemed to be on the wrong end of a dominant pitching outing by No. 10 Middletown North and its ace, Seton Hall-bound Madi Boyce.
Boyce was perfect through the first five innings, with 13 strikeouts.
“We didn’t follow our plan as much as I would’ve liked to, but credit to her, she threw really, really well,” Morris Catholic coach Nick DeGennaro said.
But then came the sixth inning.
Natalie Carovillano broke up Boyce’s perfect game after getting hit by a pitch to lead off the inning and after Boyce got two straight strikeouts, Savannah Mead broke up the no-hitter and singled to send Carovillano to third. A Sofia Reisinger walk loaded the bases with two outs and that’s when Dunn delivered the knockout blow.
END 6 | Morris Catholic breaks this game wide open on a 3-run double off the wall by Rachel Dunn. Crusaders lead 3-0. pic.twitter.com/FLZ85Vk4Y7
— Jake Aferiat (@Jake_Aferiat) April 19, 2025
And though Dunn hit just .200 last year, she’s raised her average 185 points this year and proven herself to be one of the biggest drivers of this Morris Catholic team.
“She was right on the whole game, so if there was a kid that was going to be up in that moment, we wanted it to be her with the way she was swinging the bat,” DeGennaro said.
Dunn felt her confidence grow from last year to this year she got more acclimated to the level of play and the speed of the game. And while she hadn’t yet faced a pitcher of Boyce’s caliber this season, she channeled that confidence as the game went on as well.
It also helped that Morris Catholic’s ace Sofia Reisinger pitched a gem of her own, allowing just one hit and three walks while striking out seven, keeping Morris Catholic in the game with every pitch and every out.
And after a 1-2 start, the Crusaders have won five in a row and haven’t given up more than three runs in any of those games.
“This team wants to be coached,” DeGennaro said. “They’re singularly focused on getting better and winning games and that’s why why we’re successful right now.”
Cedar Grove caps off evening with comeback win
The final game of the day pitted No. 6 Cedar Grove against No. 7 Immaculate Heart, and almost immediately, it was apparent that a slugfest was about to ensue.
It was a 4-3 game after the first inning as both Cedar Grove and IHA got hard hit balls, including one by Cayce Kavakich that left the yard for Cedar Grove en route to a 13-7 win.
From there, the two teams traded blows back and forth until IHA’s three-time All-State catcher Gabby Shadek launched her first of two home runs over the centerfield fence to put Immaculate Heart up 6-5 after four innings.
Both sides went scoreless in the fifth before Cedar Grove exploded for eight runs in the sixth inning and put the game away for good.
Marina Bryant led the team with three RBI, while Gia Fernandez, Ava Oeckel, Gabby Florre and Kavakich all drove in multiple runs and Fernandez, Oeckel, Kavakich and Florre each had multiple hits as well.
Jake Aferiat can be reached at [email protected]. Follow him at @Jake_Aferiat.
The N.J. High School Sports newsletter is now appearing in mailboxes 5 days a week. Sign up now!
Follow us on social: Facebook | Instagram | X (formerly Twitter)