What’s the most romantic place in America? It might just be a New Jersey beachside restaurant and bar.
Take a stroll down Beacon Avenue in Sea Girt and you’ll come across a Victorian-style beach house that's always bustling, complete with a long line of eager visitors. Ask anyone in town about The Parker House, and they’ll stop you in your tracks, likely calling it legendary. This restaurant by day, bar by night, has been serving up great food and music since 1878 — and sparking hundreds of love stories along the way, like that of Larry and Valerie Doyle.
In the summer of 1985, Larry and Valerie exchanged glances across The Parker House bar, but then Larry worked up the courage to walk over and strike up a conversation. However, it didn’t take long for the sea of people at the bar to separate the pair, almost ending their story right then and there.
“That was that, possibly never to be seen again,” Valerie, 62, tells PEOPLE about the abrupt ending to their initial interaction.
Both spent the following days wondering what could have been. “I was thinking about her a lot, like, ‘How could I have not gotten her last name and phone number?,’ ” Larry, 64, remembers. Valerie adds, “I went on a date with a lifeguard and remember wishing it was Larry.”
Then, as fate — or perhaps The Parker House — would have it, two weeks later, the pair locked eyes across the bar once again. This time, neither was willing to let the opportunity slip away.
“I made a beeline and said, ‘We’re going out,’ ” Larry recalls.
Forty years of marriage, four kids and one grandchild — with another on the way — later, the pair has never questioned falling in love at The Parker House, and even celebrated Valerie’s 60th birthday there in 2022. “We’re soulmates,” Larry says. “I knew right then and there she was the one for me.”
High School Sweethearts Rekindle Romance 7 Decades Later — and Can’t Stop Cuddling: 'We're Like Teenagers'
While countless love stories have unfolded within the walls of the New Jersey hotspot, its magic doesn't just work on the inside. One summer afternoon in 2021, Kurt and Ashley Naslonski both found themselves standing in the hour-long line to enter the bar.
“I saw an old friend in line, and he introduced me to [his friends], including Kurt,” Ashley, 29, recalls. After passing each other “at least 10 times” in the snaking line, the pair grabbed a drink inside, spending the rest of the night dancing together to the Jersey Shore-famous Pat Roddy Band, which went on to perform at their wedding welcome party at The Parker House in October.
“We’ve had so many good memories there,” Kurt, 31, tells PEOPLE, as Ashley adds, “We just love doing life together.”
5 Real-Life Love Stories That Will Warm Your Heart This Valentine's Day
Of course, some Parker House love stories are still being written.
On her 21st birthday in 2018, Carley Gatta stepped into the bar's basement looking to celebrate. What she found instead was Matthew Golden, a fellow gluten-free bargoer with drink recommendations, like the bar’s quintessential drink, the “Spring Laker.”
“We hit it off right away,” Matthew, 28, says.
Six years later, to the day, the pair got engaged, and are looking forward to their July wedding as well as the “whole next chapter of life.”
“There’s so much history,” Gatta, 27, says about The Parker House, where they also took their engagement photos. “It just attracts so many people.”
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
When it comes to the bar's influence, well, let's just say it doesn't stop at just bringing couples together.
Pamela and Matt Cleaves grew up as friends and slowly fell in love, spending much of their time together biking to The Parker House for lunch and participating in the establishment’s annual “fun runs.”
After getting married there in 2019 — “It was something special,” Matt, 39, tells PEOPLE about what the venue means to them — they had a son in 2021, and it is no surprise what they named him. “When we found out it was a boy, we were like, ‘Yeah, he’ll be named Parker,’” Pamela, 36, says.
Matt adds, “He’ll have the best opening line for whoever he wants to talk to.”
If their kids — the couple had a daughter earlier this year — went on to fall in love at The Parker House, Pamela says they’d be “so happy.”
She adds, "I’d make them have their wedding there, too."