EAST FLAT ROCK — A daycare in East Flat Rock is being forced to leave the church where it has operated for 25 years, leaving dozens of families scrambling to find childcare. The imminent closing underscores the scarcity of childcare in Henderson County.
Tomorrow’s Hope Child Development Center, a nonprofit, has been located in a building at Hope United Methodist Church for decades. The childcare operation's director, Terry Maybin, told the Hendersonville Times-News Nov. 12 that it has always paid its rent to the church, and that for many years, the relationship was harmonious, with church members ministering to children.
In April 2023, believing that the church was shifting its priorities to help the homeless and poor — partly because homeless people were sometimes hanging around or sleeping near the premises — the daycare's leaders decided to cease its operations by August 2025. It stopped enrolling new children but still serves 38 of them, down from 86 at its peak.
The church doubled the rent last year, Maybin said. Still, a letter from the church dated Oct. 29 came as a surprise.
“The Board voted unanimously to end this monthly rental with Tomorrow’s Hope,” the letter read. “Kindly consider this letter as notice to vacate by Dec. 31, 2024, at 5 p.m. At that time, the locks will be changed. We will be showing the space to additional renters, effective immediately.”
The letter listed seven people and "2 unnamed members" as signatories.
"It was just a coincidence that we were having a daycare board meeting with all my board members when the certified letter was delivered, and we were all just — I mean, this is nothing that we would ever expect, especially from a church," Maybin said.
"To do this at Christmas, after a hurricane, has just blown us away," she said. Church leaders have not given her, nor the affected families, an explanation for their decision, despite requests, she said.
Emily Fleming, a physical therapist, sends her sons, ages 4 and 1, to Tomorrow’s Hope. She said, in an email that she sent to church leaders and shared with the Hendersonville Times-News, that it is one of only two 5-star rated daycare centers in Henderson County that accept infants and are open for full day care.
Fleming said multiple facilities had advised that it would be 15 to 18 months to accommodate her children. Neither she nor her husband are in a position to quit their jobs, and her fellow parents from Tomorrow's Hope are educators, healthcare professionals, and other essential workers, she wrote.
“When we toured a daycare in town in April 2023 we were told we were already number SEVEN on the waitlist for a spot for the 2025-2026 school year,” Fleming wrote. “Please understand the dire situation that is daycare availability in Henderson and surrounding countries.”
Maybin said parents typically need to have their child's name on a waitlist for a year to secure a spot for an infant. For older children, the wait is about six to nine months.
According to a report released this year by the U.S. Chamber Foundation, employee turnover and absenteeism due to childcare issues costs North Carolina employers an estimated $4.29 billion per year.
The North Carolina Early Education Coalition has described the state as a "childcare desert," with an average of more than five families competing for every open slot in a licensed childcare facility. Families spend on average $633 per month for care. Tomorrow's Hope charges $190 per week for infants and $175 per week for older children.
This summer, the state government authorized $68 million for grants to help childcare providers because pandemic-era grants from the federal government are ending. NC Child has warned that without additional investments in child care, up to 30% of child care centers in North Carolina could close their doors.
Damage from Hurricane Helene caused 55 childcare centers in Western North Carolina to close, according to the N.C. Department of Health and Human Services (NCDHHS).
Families have been asking the church to allow Tomorrow’s Hope to remain open until August 2025.
"Unfortunately, this is simply a matter of the church needing to make a very difficult decision," church pastor Danielle Hammett told the Times-News Nov. 12 via email.
"To clarify, we are not evicting the preschool from the property, as there are no legal proceedings related to this decision," Hammett added. "This is simply a non-renewal of their month-to-month rental agreement with the church." She said they had given the daycare 60 days' notice to vacate—more than the standard 30 days.
Hammett shared a statement from the church, which said that its Community Board had voted unanimously to end the agreement with the daycare, and had the support of the congregation.
"The church can no longer fully support the daycare center's utilization of its facilities and has reached a regrettable impasse," the statement said. "The leadership of Hope UMC does not take this matter lightly, as we recognize how important childcare is to families."
The statement expressed sadness and a commitment to keep ministering to the East Flat Rock community.
Kenneth H. Carter, Jr., resident bishop of the Western North Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church, did not respond to a request for comment Nov. 12.
Maybin said she has been calling other childcare facilities, trying to help families find alternate arrangements. She was hopeful that a new daycare opening in Hendersonville, Kid City USA, might be able to accommodate them. She was also trying to help her childcare staff — all of whom have worked at the center for 12 to 25 years — find new jobs.
Deirdra Funcheon covers Henderson, Polk and Transylvania Counties for the Hendersonville Times-News. Got a tip? Email her at [email protected].