Two white cement piers with a big blue sign that hung between them announcing "Entrance to Pinecliff Lake" are remembered by long-time residents with a Main Street (Union Valley Road) recollection of West Milford Village of the past. A real estate office was on the left hand side of the entry road (Vista Road) to Pinecliff Lake – next to where Century 21 Real Estate is now located - in the 1930s.
In his writings about the West Milford Village area of 80 years ago, the late Arthur Cahill noted this early real estate office was where Mrs. LaRoe, Lou Brown and Joseph Gormley were the agents for home sales and rentals. More recently the current brick building of Century 21 Real Estate on the site was built by the late Real Estate Broker Nell McCann, who was also with Century 21.
"There were only a couple of year-round homes in the development (in the 1940s)," wrote Cahill.
"All the others were summer vacation homes with no heat or water available when the summer season ended."
He said the original water supply for the Pinecliff Lake community was supplied by a gravity-feed reservoir at the top of Cliff Road. A large pipe brought the water down to the main line along Bearfort Road and to the other side of the lake to Pinecliff Lake Drive where feeder lines took the water into the homes, continued Cahill.
The water was shut off just after the end of October and it was turned on again about May 1.
"This was some (difficult) job because all the lines had to be shut off and drained because they ran along the top of the ground or were just down in the ground a couple of inches," continued Cahill. "All the pipes in the homes had to be drained too."
If the water remained in the pipes during the sub-zero West Milford temperatures there was danger that any water left in them would freeze and break the pipes.
Cahill remembered Arthur Wilson as being the man in charge of everything at Pinecliff Lake. It was Wilson who took care of the water system.
All the roads at the Pinecliff community originally were unpaved – dirt roads. Cahill recalled that Wilson used a large road grader machine to grade the roads. He made sure all the drainage ditches were open and did any repairs that came up around the development.
Mail was delivered out of the Newfoundland Post Office along Union Valley Road to the point of where it intersects with Route 511 (Greenwood Lake Turnpike) in Hewitt. In the 1950s mail was still delivered from Newfoundland by the late carrier Leslie (Les) Post. He lived in Texas with his daughter.
A man and woman in charge of the clubhouse were recalled by Cahill as being Willie and Anna Pfeiffer. He said they frowned on kids from the West Milford Lakes community coming over to Pinecliff Lake.
"We managed to sneak over in the evenings and have fun with the girls," said Cahill. "I don’t know who may ever read this story so I better not go into any details."
He said fishing was good off the dam by the spillway. Perch and bass were caught there, he recalled. Cahill remembered that once in while the boys would be spotted from someone from Pinecliff Lake. Then they were made to throw the fish back and leave that area. If they saw someone coming in time the boys would run from the dam onto the road and head for home, he said.
"I’ll never forget the times we had with Mr. Goebel’s wagon that he carried his rowboat on," remembered Cahill. "He had a four wheel horse buggy with two axles and a frame up the middle and a rope around the front axle near the wheels for steering. We would lift the boat off the buggy and ride down the hill on the buggy."
He told a tale of one night when they were moving fast down the hill and the rope they used for steering broke.
"Into the ditch we went!" said Cahill. "All the right side wheels had broken spokes. We picked up the spokes, dragged the wagon back up the hill, put the boat on it and laid the spokes by the wagon. I bet that puzzled him for awhile! Somehow he found out that some kids were responsible for this – but then again – what kids would do a thing like that?"