Anyone who has lived in or driven through Pompton Plains over the past several decades knows that Route 23 has long been the community's commercial backbone. Ten of thousands of motorists travel the corridor each day, passing the businesses that serve local families and help define the character of the area.
Like many established suburban shopping centers across New Jersey, however, some of these properties had begun to show their age. Built for a different generation of retail, many had seen only limited reinvestment over the years, leaving them with aging infrastructure, outdated architecture, and tenant layouts that no longer reflected the needs of today's businesses.
One of the most visible examples has been Fireside Plaza, located at 679-717 State Route 23.
Get local news you can trust in your inbox
After nearly four decades without a major renovation, the approximately 30,000-square-foot shopping center had become a familiar landmark whose best days appeared to be behind it. Aging storefronts, worn pavement, outdated building systems, and a deteriorating exterior no longer reflected the vibrant community surrounding it.
Today, that picture is changing.
A nearly $2 million redevelopment is transforming Fireside Plaza into a modern neighborhood shopping destination while preserving the property's longstanding place within the community. Construction is expected to be substantially completed by September 2026, marking one of the most significant private reinvestments in this stretch of Route 23 in recent years.
Rather than simply updating the appearance of the property, the project has involved rebuilding much of the shopping center from the ground up.
Visitors will immediately notice the contemporary façade, redesigned storefronts, new sidewalks, modern lighting, a resurfaced parking lot, and a striking new pylon sign that gives the center a renewed presence along one of northern New Jersey's busiest commercial corridors.
Less visible—but equally important—are the improvements beneath the surface.
The redevelopment includes a completely new sewer system replacing the property's aging septic infrastructure, along with new plumbing, electrical service, HVAC systems, and utilities throughout the newly configured tenant spaces. A new roof and extensive structural upgrades ensure that the improvements are more than cosmetic, positioning the property to serve both businesses and residents for decades to come.
The project has also reimagined how the shopping center functions.
Instead of relying on a traditional large-format anchor tenant, the interior has been redesigned to accommodate a broader mix of retailers and service providers. That flexibility allows the center to better reflect the way neighborhood shopping has evolved, creating opportunities for businesses that offer convenience, health, wellness, dining, and everyday services in one accessible location.
That vision is already beginning to take shape.
Several new businesses have committed to the property, with additional lease negotiations currently underway. Among the expected additions are a neighborhood gym and a wellness spa - businesses that will expand the services available to local residents while bringing new daily activity to the center.
For communities like Pompton Plains, projects of this kind represent more than a fresh coat of paint.
Well-designed commercial spaces contribute to the overall appearance of a town, support local businesses, encourage additional private investment, and create places where residents genuinely enjoy spending time. As older shopping centers are thoughtfully modernized rather than abandoned or replaced, they help preserve the identity of established communities while adapting to changing market demands.
Across New Jersey, municipalities are increasingly recognizing that redevelopment often begins not with large-scale new construction, but with the careful reinvestment of properties that already occupy prominent locations within their communities.
Fireside Plaza is an example of that philosophy in action.
The redevelopment is being led by , a boutique real estate investment firm based in Englewood, New Jersey, with two decades of experience specializing in value-add commercial real estate. Rather than focusing exclusively on new construction, the firm has built its reputation by identifying properties with untapped potential and investing in the improvements needed to give them a new chapter.
For David Zoarets and Yaron Shemesh, founders of Prime Equity NYC, this project represents far more than a simple commercial renovation.
“We believe that the true value in real estate comes from breathing new life into existing properties and investing in communities where people live and work. Our goal is not just modernize buildings, but to create places where businesses can thrive, and communities can take pride.”
While large institutional investors often pursue landmark developments, boutique firms frequently play a different role- working on projects that have an immediate and meaningful impact on the communities they serve.
As construction enters its final stages, Fireside Plaza is quickly becoming more than a renovated shopping center. It is emerging as a symbol of what thoughtful reinvestment can accomplish when long-term vision is paired with careful execution.
While large institutional investors often pursue landmark developments, boutique firms frequently play a different role- working on projects that have an immediate and meaningful impact on the communities they serve.
As construction enters its final stages, Fireside Plaza is quickly becoming more than a renovated shopping center. It is emerging as a symbol of what thoughtful reinvestment can accomplish when long-term vision is paired with careful execution.
For residents, the result will be an attractive, modern retail destination offering new services close to home. For neighboring property owners, it demonstrates the value of continued investment along the Route 23 corridor. And for Pompton Plains as a whole, it represents another step toward strengthening the commercial landscape that serves as one of the community's front doors.
Sometimes the most meaningful transformations are not measured by building something entirely new.
Sometimes they come from recognizing the potential in places that have been part of a community for generations, and giving them the opportunity to thrive once again.