John Harbaugh, rightfully so with his resume, is going to do things his way. Not the way that fans, media, or other pundits believe is the correct path. And that led to a quarterback change that has a chance to alter the Giants’ season.
The general consensus was that it made sense to give Jameis Winston one last chance to prove himself. J.J. McCarthy has only had about three weeks to learn the playbook, and the bye week after Sunday’s game in Houston would be a more natural transition period to a new quarterback.
But Harbaugh has repeatedly acted with urgency in his first season as Giants head coach. He’s not interested in playing it safe.
“We’re trying to win the division,” Harbaugh said. “We’re trying to take it as far as we can and win as many games as we can. We’ve got goals.”
At 3-2-1 and with a 1.5-game lead over the Eagles and Cowboys, the Giants have a legitimate chance to win the NFC East for the first time since 2011.
Few could have expected that before the season with Harbaugh installing a brand-new program, but expectations must be adjusted when conditions change. The Giants are the latest example that the right coaching can shift a franchise’s fortunes quickly.
Yet they’ve reached a point where the season could fall apart if they don’t rediscover their identity on offense quickly. That’s why they’re turning to McCarthy right now.
“When we lost Jaxson (Dart), that made it tough for us to exactly be what we said we wanted to be, so that changed everything, and we were trying to find ourselves a little bit for a few weeks there. We still have been, honestly,” Harbaugh said two days before officially benching Winston for McCarthy. “It’s our responsibility now to find ourselves and to put together the type of football team that can go get what we want. It’s all right there for us. We have an opportunity to do it.”
To Harbaugh’s point, all summer the Giants built their offense around Dart’s abilities to scramble and run read-options. That vanished when Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury in Week 2 because Winston isn’t nearly as mobile.
They went 2-1-1 with Winston as the starter, but that was mostly in spite of Winston’s production — except for when he rallied them to a 27-27 tie in Washington with 326 passing yards and three touchdowns. Even in that game, though, they couldn’t run the ball. That held them back in last Sunday’s loss to the Saints. It would doom them in the tough schedule ahead.
McCarthy’s legs will keep defenses from loading the box as much. This week may not be the greatest indicator against a Texans team that is rounding into form and features the second-best run defense (3.4 yards per rush). Still, it will be fascinating to see what McCarthy can do for four quarters after throwing for 243 yards in 11 minutes against the Saints.
This is why the Giants traded a fifth-round pick for McCarthy. Both sides believe a fresh start can unlock the 10th pick in the 2024 draft, who said that “understanding the nature of NFL football” is where he’s grown the most since last starting a game with the Vikings last January.
“It’s extremely different from college football,” McCarthy said. “Just being able to be smart and respond in the right situations, and understand like, ‘Hey, I can force this here, I shouldn’t force this here.’ And just kind of having more of a feel of NFL defenses and schemes of the specific coordinators and coaching trees and just compartmentalizing specific stuff.”
Beyond the quarterback position, the Giants must eliminate their absurd rotation of running backs — and it appears they will against the Texans.
Harbaugh said he wanted to see one of the backs “take the bull by the horns” against the Saints, but spreading 14 carries among three players wasn’t conducive to success. That position is about rhythm, and veering away from one back for multiple drives because he didn’t rip off a long run with a couple carries made no sense.
Harbaugh later indicated that they tried something different because the run game struggled in previous games even when they leaned more into one back. Cam Skattebo will likely be the lead back in Houston after being benched for a game because of fumbling issues, and Tyrone Tracy Jr., who had two touchdowns against the Saints, should get ample chances in this game as well.
If all goes well with McCarthy adding another dimension like Dart did and the running game operating efficiently like it did in Week 1 against the Cowboys, the Giants will be back to playing the power football that they established in camp.
“We’ve got to be able to run the ball. You cannot be one-dimensional in this league,” offensive coordinator Matt Nagy said. “You certainly cannot be one-dimensional against the Houston Texans. That’s trouble if you do that. I think for us, we want to make sure that we let these guys, we work together with them and put in good schemes, but then they’ve got to execute well.”
Greg Johnson covers the New York Giants and NFL for MediaNews Group. Reach him at [email protected].
Giants Gameday
The Game: Giants (3-2-1) at Texans (2-4), Reliant Stadium, Houston, Texas, Sunday, 1 p.m. (FOX)
The Line: Houston by 10.5
History: The Giants lead the all-time series, 5-1, with five wins in a row. The last meeting was in 2022 in East Rutherford. The Texans’ only win came in the first meeting in 2002 in Houston.
Key Matchups:
Giants LT Andrew Thomas/RT Jermaine Eluemunor vs. Texans DEs Will Anderson/Danielle Hunter: The expectation is that both Giants tackles, who are among the NFL’s best, will play despite nursing injuries. Anderson and Hunter represent the best pass-rushing duo in the league. They have combined for 10.5 sacks and 21 QB hits this season.
Giants RB Cam Skattebo vs. Texans run defense: Skattebo appears to be out of the doghouse after getting no carries last week because of fumbling issues, but this is a tough matchup. The second-year back is averaging only 3.6 yards per carry, and the Texans are tied for the second-fewest yards allowed per rush (3.4).
Giants OLB Kayvon Thibodeaux vs. Texans LT Aireontae Ersery/RT Trent Brown: Thibodeaux hasn’t put up flashy numbers (zero sacks and one QB hit this season), but he posted three pressures and three run stops vs. the Saints last week, according to Pro Football Focus, and has made other plays that don’t show up in the box score. A relatively weak Texans offensive line is a chance to make more noise.
Giants CB Paulson Adebo vs. Texans WR Nico Collins: Adebo is expected to play after a five-game absence with a knee injury, and he’ll need to step back into a starting spot with Greg Newsome II injured. He’ll likely see some snaps against Collins, who is averaging 80.8 yards per game.
Injury Report:
Giants: OUT: OLB Tremaine Edmunds (shoulder), CB Greg Newsome II (concussion); DOUBTFUL: TE Theo Johnson (neck); QUESTIONABLE: RT Jermaine Eluemunor (calf), S Jevón Holland (concussion), OL Marcus Mbow (knee), CB Paulson Adebo (knee), S Tyler Nubin (neck).
Texans: OUT: S Reed Blankenship (concussion/hand), OT Blake Fisher (thumb), RB David Montgomery (groin), S Jalen Pitre (shoulder); QUESTIONABLE: WR Tank Dell (knee).
Giant Facts: J.J. McCarthy is the Giants’ 11th different starting QB since Eli Manning retired after the 2019 season. … OLB Abdul Carter ranks second in the NFL with 15 quick QB pressures (pressures within 2.5 seconds of the ball being snapped), per Next Gen Stats. … The NFC East is the only division since the AFL-NFL merger in 1970 to go two straight weeks without any wins among the four teams.
The Prediction: Texans 27, Giants 17