MUNCIE, IN — After 35 years, members of the Muncie Light Horse Club have reached the end of the trail, at least as far as Prairie Creek Reservoir goes.
On Friday, Aug. 1, the city of Muncie shut down about five miles of horse trails that had been on the west side of the reservoir since 1990.
The club's current president, Greg Wilkins, and his wife, Nancy, joined the organization in 1991. They are its longest-serving current members.
Indiana American Water Company, which owns the reservoir and surrounding property, made the decision to close the trails.
While Greg and Nancy Wilkins, and other club members, wish the water company would reconsider its decision, they acknowledge IAWC has the authority to take that action.
"This is the water company's property," Greg Wilkins said in an interview a few days before the trails were closed. "I completely respect that. They can do with it what they want."
At a meeting last spring where the future of the horse trails was discussed, a water company official's remarks might have given some an incorrect impression of the situation.
The Muncie Light Horse Club — which for the past several years had access to a large lot along the western shore of the reservoir accessible to the trails — was not at that location without invitation.
Greg Wilkins said an official with then-Mayor Sharon McShurley's administration "approached our club about adopting this property as our own."
"We were already taking care of the trails, and they knew that," he said.
The property, including a large storage building, had previously been used by member of a model boat club that apparently disbanded.
"This (land) turned into a home for vagrants, people dumping trash," Wilkins said. "We cleared the property up, made it our own. And we've been here ever since.
"We're here because they invited us."
The horse club's use of the property continued during the administration of McShurley's successor as Muncie mayor, Dennis Tyler, who had electricity and water service made available at a small campground used by the horse enthusiasts.
Any suggestions the trails were not well maintained were reportedly inaccurate.
"This is such a jewel for this area," Nancy Wilkins said. "People who aren't horse people don't understand — these are the nicest trails. You would be hard pressed to find any better trails than we have right here.
"We have spent thousands of hours and thousands of dollars of our own money and our own blood, sweat and tears in this trail system."
Since the fall of 2023, more than $12,000 in grant money the horse club received has been invested in maintaining the trails.
This year, $2,000 in grant money was used for removal of invasive honeysuckle from the sides of the trails.
"The trails are in nice shape now," Greg Wilkins said.
Wilkins has acknowledged the trails since 1996 have been classified as "wildlife habitat" but noted guidelines from the Indiana Department of Natural Resources allows for horse trails in such areas.
Water company officials have said horses can't be permitted "around a drinking water reservoir."
Greg Wilkins called the use of the horse trails "the least polluting, most ecological recreational activity out here."
Water company officials have also indicated they can find no paperwork that confirms the company was informed of plans to create horse trails on the west side of the reservoir in 1990.
The city leases the 750 acres of land surrounding the 1,275-acre reservoir for use as a park. Ron Bonham, superintendent of the Prairie Creek park for 38 years who helped create the trails, died in 2016.
After announcing plans to close the horse trails in mid-July, Mayor Dan Ridenour noted the city's lease with the water company "says that the entire west side of the lake is to be preservation and conservation."
Greg Wilkins noted the water company expressed no concerns about the horse trails when they renewed the lease in 2012.
The Muncie Light Horse Club — founded in 1942, and now a nonprofit organization — will remain in operation.
Greg and Nancy Wilkins noted there are other horse trails available, including a 3-mile trail along the Cardinal Greenway south of Prairie Creek Reservoir that many used at the same time they rode the reservoir trails.
Other options include horse trails in Westwood Park near New Castle and those at state parks, including Whitewater or Versailles.
But Greg Wilkins continues to hope that somehow, the decision to close the local trails his organization has used and maintained for decades might be reconsidered.
"We benefit this side of the reservoir by being here," he said.
Douglas Walker is a news reporter at The Star Press. Contact him at 765-213-5851 or at [email protected].