WOODBURY — The Region 14 Board of Education is headed back to the drawing board after its proposed 2025-26 budget failed for a second time this week.
Voters in Bethlehem and Woodbury on Tuesday rejected the $42.8 million plan with a count of 1,003 to 926, a margin of 77 votes. Bethlehem residents voted against the proposal, 425 - 160, while Woodbury residents voted 766 - 578 in favor of the plan.
The budget, since being defeated the first time on May 6, had been trimmed by $470,000, much of it cuts to staffing.
“It’s devastating to Region 14,” Superintendent of Schools Brian Murphy said Wednesday. “Unfortunately, our ability to meet the educational needs of our students will be compromised.”
This most recent failed budget proposal represented a 3.85% increase in spending. The first failed budget proposal had requested an increase of 4.99%, a figure Murphy said was required simply to maintain the district’s status quo.
A third referendum had not been scheduled yet but would likely be held on a Tuesday in early June. Last year’s school budget was defeated twice before being approved on the third try at a 2.8% increase.
Voters in both towns have been vocal in their opposition to the school budget, which, as proposed, amounts to an estimated $30,000 per pupil expense.
That sentiment was reflected in a handful of lawn signs spotted around both towns leading up to this week’s vote, one stating, “vote yes for higher taxes,” another reading, “feed the greed.”
School officials are now faced with having to make cuts on top of ones already made since the budget first failed earlier this month. Those cuts include the elimination of a guidance counselor position at Nonnewaug High School and a high school lab technician. Both individuals could lose their jobs as a result, Murphy said.
Other positions cut included the Nonnewaug High School dean of students/athletic director, Mitchell Elementary School kindergarten teacher, and an elementary school Spanish teacher, although no one is currently serving in those positions.
The library media specialist position at Bethlehem Elementary School was reduced from full-time to part-time.
“A total of $800,000 has been cut so far out of the Region 14 education budget over the past two years,” Murphy said.
Impact of Agriscience program
Many locals say the biggest issue for voters in both towns appears to be that Region 14, by being host to the Ellis Clark Regional Agriscience program, has been left to pay more than its fair share.
Ellis Clark at Nonnewaug High School accepts students from towns around the area. The state provides a per-student grant and sending districts pay tuition, with the amount capped by the Educational Cost Sharing formula and previous year's tuition. The formula leaves a gap that Region 14 ends up covering.
Woodbury First Selectman Barbara Parkinson said the idea that Bethlehem and Woodbury are forced to subsidize out-of-towners has long been an issue in Region 14, one that may have played a role in four out of the last five school budget referendums over the past two years being defeated.
“It’s a legislative issue that needs to be addressed in Hartford,” Perkinson said Wednesday. “It’s a problem and has been for a long time, but voting the budget down won’t solve the problem.”
Murphy said the district continues to lobby the state for more tuition money.
"I want to be very clear that every school district in Connecticut that accepts out-of-district agriscience students does not receive full freight of tuition to attend the program," Murphy said. "This is a state of Connecticut funding issue."
However, he said if the 262 out-of-district agri-science students stopped attending Region 14 schools, “we would have to collapse or close 47 high school courses.”
Board of Education Chairman James Crocker recently proposed the establishment of a committee to take a closer look at the current funding involved in the agriscience program.