Move sparks dispute between mayor and three council members over fire chief appointment
MONROE, La. (KNOE) - Monroe City Council member Juanita Woods made a motion less than three minutes into Tuesday’s meeting to pass over the agenda and adjourn without discussing any items.
“I would like to make a motion that we pass over this agenda for the evening,” Woods said.
Council member Rodney McFarland and Council Chairman Verbon Muhammad voted with Woods. Councilwoman Gretchen Ezernack voted against the motion. Councilman Doug Harvey was not at the meeting.
“Motion carried, this meeting is adjourned,” the meeting record states.
Council reaction
Ezernack was the only council member who voted against ending the meeting early. She asked Woods why she wanted to end the meeting early but did not receive a response.
“I feel like it was being totally irresponsible to the citizens of Monroe, to the people there in the audience at the meeting and those that had issues that needed to be resolved that were on the agenda,” Ezernack said.
Ezernack said that in her 16 years on the council, she has never seen a meeting end this way, and she does not know why members of the council voted to close it.
Mayor Friday Ellis addressed the meeting’s ending.
“It didn’t have to go down that way, but that’s a decision they made. The charter gives them that authority, but you’re not immune from the consequences of your decisions,” Ellis said.
Council members respond
On Wednesday, McFarland and Woods went live on Facebook, saying one reason for the meeting’s abrupt ending is that Ellis refuses to work with certain members of the council.
“He tried to paint a picture last night after he got all mad and stormed out. As if we’re hurting the city, you hurting the city, Friday Ellis, because you have made it up in your doggone mind that you’re not gonna work with the black council persons,” McFarland said.
Woods, McFarland and Muhammad are the three African American members on the Monroe City Council, representing the 3rd, 4th and 5th districts, respectively. Ellis said those districts have seen the most projects and funding during his tenure as mayor.
“Up to 90% of the city’s capital infrastructure funds have all benefited districts 3, 4, and five. The same 3 council members who voted this down. Every year we have appropriation asks in DC. Every one of those appropriation asks, districts 3, 4, and five. Our capital outlay projects in Baton Rouge that benefit this city all benefit districts 3, 4, and five. So again, they have accusations. We have receipts, it’s all public knowledge,” Ellis said.
No one addressed the council from the podium during Tuesday’s meeting before the agenda was dismissed.
“The items that was on the agenda. Yes, they were. They were passed over. In other words, two weeks later we’ll we’ll pick it back up. But we want to open communication with the mayor,” McFarland said.
Impact on residents, business owners
Ellis said the decision to skip the agenda mostly affected residents and business owners in attendance, some of whom came to hear about city issues while others sought to open a nonprofit or restaurant.
“What you hurt last night were business owners, nonprofits, first responders, contractors and people interested in doing the business of the city and the people who actually took the time to participate in a public meeting,” Ellis said.
Aaron, the owner of Gonzalez Mexican Restaurant, attended Tuesday’s meeting to seek a new alcohol-selling license for his Monroe location. He said he cannot open the location until he has the license.
“He’s losing money and he has to be closed for a while because he can’t get a liquor license, so it affects him a lot,” the Gonzalez owner said.
Fire chief dispute
Muhammad said in a statement that the meeting’s ending was not solely about the fire chief position.
“This is not about the fire chief, it’s bigger than that. It’s about inclusion, equity, and fairness in projects, contracts and the distribution of resources in this city,” Muhammad said.
The meeting came one week after Gov. Jeff Landry re-appointed Timothy Williams as Monroe fire chief, a decision McFarland, Woods and Muhammad have said they are challenging in court. Ellis said he believes that issue sparked the meeting’s ending.
“It’s already been told it’s about the fire chief and it’s about ultimately stating that you’re going to respect our authority as counsel. Well, right now that’s there are legal avenues to challenge that. They’re already being pursued. So again, you’ve chosen to pursue this through the courts. Let it go through the courts. And if the courts deem it unconstitutional, then they deem it unconstitutional or vice versa,” Ellis said.
The Monroe fire chief position has been vacant for almost two years. Woods said that is because Ellis will not collaborate with the city council on the decision.
“But Mr. Ellis is the one that’s been holding up this process. It has not been the council. And if two years has passed and you hadn’t had a fire chief, that’s Ellis’s fault. That’s not the council’s fault because all he had to do was have the conversation,” Woods said.
Emails dated May 30 from Timothy Williams to all members of the Monroe City Council show Williams introducing himself and asking to set up a meeting with each member to discuss his qualifications to be Monroe fire chief. The city council never responded to Williams’ inquiry.
Woods and Muhammad were asked who they would want to see as fire chief if not Williams but did not answer. Muhammad said last year he would like to see someone from within Monroe Fire become chief, but he was one of the council members who voted against Monroe Fire Capt. Daniel Overturf in 2024.
The full 3-minute, 27-second meeting can be viewed at KNOE.com or on the station’s YouTube page.