NEWARK — Coach Josh Hendershot was beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel for the Newark Catholic football program, but he knew he could not erase 6-24.
The Green Wave will enter the 2026 season with renewed optimism, hoping the results of an arduous rebuild will start paying off. Hendershot, however, will not be there to lead them as the school recently dismissed him.
"We're a results-driven society, and I understood things can change at any instant," Hendershot said. "The expectations are obviously high and rightfully so. It was not necessarily an inkling per se, but I was always aware in the back of my mind."
Hendershot, a 2010 NC graduate, was hired in 2023 with the Green Wave coming off of three consecutive Division VII regional championships, including a trip to the state final in 2021. Injuries and defections over time, however, decimated the roster.
Declining enrollment also contributed to record-low numbers in the program, NC finished 3-7, 1-9 and 2-8, the latter two the worst seasons in program history, under Hendershot. The next coach will inherit a roster that returns what was a productive junior class.
Check out the all new PLAY hub with puzzles, games and more!
"We just got together and decided we needed to go in a different direction," NC athletic director Rob Smith said. "I will keep it pretty simple with that."
Hendershot was an All-Ohio lineman at NC before earning Mid-American Conference honors at Toledo. He had assistant coaching experience at the Division I college level before coming home to NC.
The Green Wave lost three games by three points or fewer despite starting the season with just three seniors. They were less competitive down the stretch in Licking County League-Cardinal Division losses to Heath and Johnstown.
"It's the same thing I have tried to preach for the last three years. 'Leave something better than how you found it.' For next year, there are so many really positive things for the program," Hendershot said. "I am really excited to watch from the outside how all of those guys do. Obviously, we're looking at roughly 13 or 14 seniors for the first time in a while with some really good juniors and a really strong sophomore class."
Smith declined to go deeper into specifics about the program’s performance under Hendershot. The school has set a deadline for applications of Nov. 28.
"I really don't want to get into the whys and why nots," Smith said. "You know ideally we would interview the first couple weeks of December if we can get some good candidates, which we will, and then try to make a decision mid-December. We just want someone to come in with some enthusiasm and that can relate to the kids."
Hendershot said he has not yet decided what his future in the sport holds. He is looking forward to spending time with his young family.
Hendershot filled his staff with fellow NC alumni. His assistants included former teammate Trevor Garber and Kelly Bourne, who was the program’s defensive coordinator when the Green Wave reached the 2012 state final.
"I'm extremely grateful for the guys I had on staff," Hendershot said. "To work at Newark Catholic, honestly, it's an honor; it's a privilege, but it's a challenge. … They helped me navigate some really tough times in terms of roster turnover or lack of numbers. This year, we had 60% new guys on the team. If it wasn't for those guys, it would have made my life more difficult."
Smith is hoping an efficient hiring process will allow the next coach to hit the ground running.
Hendershot said “expectations” multiple times in a short interview. He declined to say whether he thought those expectations must be slightly altered, but he noted better days are ahead for the Green Wave.
"Again, we are a results-driven society, which is awesome, but is always does need to mirror what you have and what's available," Hendershot said. "I am really excited for next year because those kids have worked their butts off. They are putting themselves in position to turn things around and really have some success."
[email protected]
740-973-4541
Instagram: @newarkurt