The track, football field and baseball fields are now officially a public park. Mater Dei Prep High School will be demolished by early fall.
MIDDLETOWN, NJ — On Wednesday, Middletown held its official acquisition ceremony as the town took ownership of the former Mater Dei Prep High School property from Saint Mary Mother of God Catholic church.
The 25-acre property is now officially a town park open to all; Mater Dei's outdoor track, football field and four baseball fields will all remain and they can be used by the public or rented out by youth and adult sports leagues.
The site, located at 538 Church Street, Middletown, will be renamed Mater Dei Park. Look for a sign to go up soon.
Mater Dei Prep closed its doors forever in 2022, citing a steep drop in student enrollment. For more than 60 years, Mater Dei provided a well-regarded Catholic education to Monmouth County teens, but enrollment had dwindled to just 220 students when it closed.
Demolition of Mater Dei High School is expected to be completed by early fall. A specific date has still not been released for when Mater Dei will be demolished. Middletown says the high school building does not meet current safety standards.
Wednesday's signing ceremony was held on the Mater Dei High School football field. The sale price is $11.75 million. In March, Middletown announced it reached an agreement to pay Saint Mary $11.75 million for the property:
75 percent of the sale price, $8,812,500, will be funded by a grant from Monmouth County, through the county's Municipal Land Preservation Incentive Program. Middletown will fund the remaining 25 percent — just under $3 million — with the money coming out of the Township’s Open Space Trust Fund.
"The county will hold a conservation easement which ensures that the new park is permanently preserved and can never be developed for non-park and recreation purposes," Monmouth County Commissioner Director Tom Arnone said at Wednesday's ceremony.
None of these plans affect St. Mary's grammar school, which will still continue to operate as usual on site and has a healthy enrollment. Middletown and St. Mary’s Church have agreed to share access to the site’s parking lot, for visitors to both the new park and the church and school.
The $11.75 million will go directly to St. Mary Mother of God; it will not go to the diocese in Trenton. This is a millions-of-dollars-cash infusion for Middletown's Catholic church. It will be used to pay down debt service, parish maintenance and start a student endorsement fund to continue Catholic education in Middletown, said St. Mary's pastor Father Jeff Kegley.
“A majority of the funds the parish receives from this purchase will go toward an endowment for St. Mary’s School to continue fostering Catholic education,” said Kegley. “St. Mary’s is one of the best schools in our diocese, and we want to ensure that it stays that way.”
Saint Mary's beloved fairs and seasonal events will also continue on site.
Middletown Mayor Tony Perry has made preserving open space in Middletown a key goal of his administration. The town's decision to purchase Mater Dei — with significant funding provided by the county — is a milestone in Perry's legacy.
“This landmark agreement symbolizes the strength of collaboration to preserve Middletown’s unique character,” said Perry Wednesday. “Through the power of shared values and strategic investment, this Township park will forever hold the memories of the terrific games, athletes, famous alumni and incredible individuals who called this place their alma mater.”