Torres did not directly answer when Patch asked if she would have voted for the 10.1 percent school tax increase earlier this year.
MIDDLETOWN, NJ — Nov. 4 will be an election for Middletown Township Committee and school board. Early in-person voting starts this Saturday, Oct. 25.
There are seven candidates running for three seats on the Middletown school board:
James Cody, Chris Aveta and Sara Weinstein (running together on the Students, Parents, Taxpayers slate), James Dobis, Erin Torres and current Board members Leonora Lacqua-Caminiti and Joe Fitzgerald.
Patch asked them all the same series of questions, and all seven got back to us. We will be publishing their candidate profiles. Here are Torres' answers:
Your name, age and office you are running for. Do you currently hold this office and if so, for how long? Both years and terms. Have you ever run for elected office before? Please list all races and their outcomes.
My name is Erin Torres, I am 42 years old, and I am running for the Middletown Board of Education. I have never run for elected office before.
What is your occupation?
I am a 20-year veteran educator with experience as a classroom teacher, administrator and union leader. Education has been my life’s work, and it’s what drives me to serve on the Board; to ensure our schools are places where students and staff can thrive.
What part of Middletown do you live in? How long have you lived in town?
After our second child was born, we “moved across the street” from our home in Atlantic Highlands to Middletown which reflected the values we hold for our children’s future. We wanted our children to grow up in a small, connected school community, a place where teachers know your name, neighbors look out for one another, and children are encouraged to find their voices. Public schools should feel personal, that community should mean something, and that every child deserves to be seen, supported, and known.
When our oldest started kindergarten last year, we knew we made the right choice.
Do you have children in the district or did your children attend Middletown schools in the past?
With three children, our youngest just one year old, we are deeply invested in Middletown’s schools for many years to come. This is our home, and I’m committed to helping it continue to grow stronger.
What specific skills or accomplishments can you cite that would compel voters to elect you to the Board of Education?
As an educator, I’ve spent my career helping people find purpose and progress even when the situation feels impossible. That’s exactly the kind of leadership our Board needs right now. I know how to meet people where they are, cut through the noise and get results that move things forward.
I’ve worked with students, teachers and administrators at every level, and I know the difference between real leadership and political theater. Our district deserves focus, honesty and accountability, not distractions and self-promotion. My experience in classrooms and administration has prepared me to restore trust, demand transparency, and keep every decision centered on our community and our children’s future. It’s time for leadership that plans, listens, and delivers.
Please list the 3 biggest issues the Middletown school district is currently facing.
The three biggest issues facing the Middletown School District are:
1. Balancing the budget responsibly.
Years of denial and short-term decisions led to the 10.1% tax hike that blindsided taxpayers. The district must find a sustainable path forward that honors the 2% tax cap, plans ahead, and uses every dollar wisely. We need a responsible, transparent budget process that plans ahead, stays within the 2% cap, and protects both our classrooms and our taxpayers.
2. Restoring trust and communication.
Right now, too many parents, staff, taxpayers and even children feel shut out of the process. Decisions are made behind closed doors, and communication breaks down until people are left confused, angry, or afraid their children won’t get the education they deserve. I’m running to rebuild that trust and will do so through open calendars, early conversations, and honest communication that keeps the community at the center of every plan.
3. Re-centering leadership on students, not politics.
The board’s focus must return to its true mission: ensuring every child in Middletown receives a safe, high-quality, and inclusive education. Leadership should reflect the community’s values of accountability, collaboration, and a commitment to the common good, not personal ambition or agendas focused on the wants of a few instead of the needs of all.
Joe and Leonora joined a majority Board vote earlier this year to increase the Middletown schools property tax by 10.1 percent. Many residents, notably seniors but also others, pleaded with the board not to increase the tax, and the district also warned it would not prevent the future closure or consolidation of some schools.
To the others not currently on the board: Would you have voted for the 10.1 percent tax increase or not? Please explain why or why not.
Years of denial and short-term thinking created this mess and I wouldn’t have let it happen. The 10.1% tax hike didn’t come out of nowhere. It was the direct result of years of poor planning, political posturing, and a lack of real accountability. For too long, the board chose to delay tough conversations, drain reserves, and pretend everything was fine until it wasn’t. That’s not leadership. That’s avoidance.
If I had been on the board, this crisis would have been addressed long before it reached taxpayers. I would have required clear, line-by-line budgets each year instead of rushed, fear-based presentations. The community deserves to know where every dollar goes and why. Fiscal responsibility means honoring the 2% cap consistently, not bending it for politics or appearances. It also means finding smart, shared solutions such as partnering with the township on Class III officers and other services before asking taxpayers for more. Our schools and township should work together, not blame each other.
This tax increase wasn’t inevitable, it was preventable. Some board members saw it coming and tried to raise concerns, but they were shut out. That’s what happens when transparency and teamwork break down. We need planners, not politicians; leaders who ask tough questions early, not make excuses later. That is the BOE member you will get when you vote for me.
In the past year, what mistakes has the Middletown BOE made? Or, asked another way: Where could the Board have done better?
Over the past year, the Middletown Board of Education has lost sight of its core responsibility: serving students, staff, and the community through transparency, collaboration, and responsible planning. The 10.1% tax increase was not an accident; it was the predictable outcome of years of denial, poor fiscal management and failure to plan within the 2% cap.
The board’s communication breakdown has deepened public frustration. Too many critical decisions have been made without full board participation or clear information, leaving families confused and distrustful. True transparency means open dialogue, active committees, and every board member having a voice.
Most concerning, politics and personal agendas have replaced focus and leadership. Instead of strengthening classrooms, too much time and money have gone to performative battles that distract from what matters most; our students, staff, and community.
Middletown deserves better. We need accountability, collaboration, and real transparency to restore trust and stability. That’s how we stop the chaos, protect taxpayers, and get back to doing what’s right for our schools.
What's your favorite thing about living in Middletown?
My favorite thing about living in Middletown is its small-town feel with big-city appeal. I’m a Jersey girl through and through, and when I first came to the area in 2016 after meeting my husband, I couldn’t believe a place like this existed. Middletown has the close-knit, neighborhood feel we always wanted. A home where people know each other, look out for one another, and take pride in their community.
What makes it truly special is the shared passion people have for this town. No matter who you are or how long you’ve lived here, we all want the same thing: to protect and strengthen what makes Middletown such a great place to live and raise a family.